Queen crest Queenzone

Daughter wants a guitar

30 posts Page 2 of 2
Thread

Posts in chronological order

Search forum
send her my way.....................................................
Bos Meg ya all.
Micrówave wrote:







magicalfreddiemercury wrote:











 







Micrówave wrote:







I provided that link for reference, I must agree with David Jones...  go to a music store if you can find one that can get this guitar.  Squiers are all the same size, so you don't have to worry about differences there.  You get a cheaper price on line, but much better service at the time of purchase and in the future.







When I read your first post, I wasn't sure if you were being serious or sarcastic. Hmm. Wonder what made me question that. :-)

Thank you for the info. I went to the site you posted and read the two reviews. I don't know what one comment means or if it really matters... maybe you can explain? It reads - "The one, and only one negative about this guitar is that there is no tone knob. It definitely needs one for leads as the humbucker is much more twangy and crisp than you would think."


The Squier Tele doesn't need a tone knob.  It is twangy and crisp... it's a humbucker.  If you're getting to the point where you have to adjust your tone, beyond using the selector switch, then you are ready to move onto a pro guitar.  I did not find it too twangy for leads, but then I don't have overdrive, distortion, flange, phaser, and fifteen other pedals plugged in at once either. 

It is a starter guitar.  A great lead player is going to go out there with a Squier.
Now that's just plain bullshit. Tone-knobs are there for a reason. A guitar sounds different with ever single amplifier you use it with; if your sound is drowning in mid-range frequencies, you turn on the tone-knob. If it's too harsh, you turn it down.

"If you're getting to the point where you have to adjust your tone,
beyond using the selector switch, then you are ready to move onto a pro
guitar"

Absolutely not. You're ready for a pro guitar when the techniques you start using outgrow your guitar (for instance, most cheaper guitars don't respond well to bending, and depending on the quality of the frets, harmonics may not sound great). Tone has nothing to do with it: the sooner you start considering tone, the better. It's one third of the totality of music (the other two being rhythm and pitch).

"A great lead player is going to go out there with a Squier."

Now that's just a matter of opinion. If you play rockabilly, sure. If you play metal, not a chance. Every guitarist needs to find the guitar (and amp) to go with their own playing and preferred sound. Most guitars that are well constructed are quite suitable for learning to play, but the closer the sound is to what the guitarist in question needs, the longer it'll take before he/she outgrows his/her first guitar.
Not Plutus but Apollo rules Parnassus
ThomasQuinn wrote: 
"Now that's just a matter of opinion. If you play rockabilly, sure. If you play metal, not a chance. Every guitarist needs to find the guitar (and amp) to go with their own playing and preferred sound. Most guitars that are well constructed are quite suitable for learning to play, but the closer the sound is to what the guitarist in question needs, the longer it'll take before he/she outgrows his/her first guitar."

===

Think "Renegade" by Styx. She wants to play the guitar solo in that.She talks about it all the time. I'm guessing that's the 'sound' she wants.
"The others don't like my interviews. And frankly, I don't care much for theirs." ~ Freddie Mercury
The guitar seems ok, but just so you know about the items that come with it.  Guitar packages are designed for parents who think this is all they'll need to buy their spoiled little one.  Only then, have they sunken their claws into you...

Includes:
[b]Amplifier[/b] - Will be suitable for a bedroom, but any other use (rehearsal, live, etc.) would require a larger amp
[i]I say that because you'll be getting a 20 pound paper weight.  If you were to buy a small combo amp, it would be quite flexable and give years of use.  Plus you'd get much better re-sale value if you were looking to upgrade.  No, you can't Mic a 5 Watt amp and sound good.[/i]

[b]Guitar Stand [/b]- Suitable, but easily knocked over.  I would suggest a wall mount.  $10

[b]Instructional DVD[/b] - worthless, get lessons.  Might teach you to re-string and play a couple of chords, but so can my Aunt Rose.

[b]Cable[/b] - cheap, you'll be replacing it soon...
[i]They say an instrument is only as good as the cable that's plugged into it.  Worth an extra $10-15 to buy a good premium cable.  Most have lifetime warranties.

[/i][b]Electronic Tuner[/b] - Cheap, you'll be replacing it soon...
[i]Again, you're going to get a bottom of the barrel Quik Tune.  It's not backlit, only tunes a certain way, doesn't offer special settings, eats 9V batteries, etc.
[/i]
[b]Gig Bag[/b] - Gonna be a while until you really need one of these.  Unless you plan on just carrying it around just because you have a guitar.   [i]Again, if re-sale is a possibility, a hard shell case is better.  Even for a $200 guitar.  Gator (brand) makes a pretty decent one for $50, Squier's is around $60.  I'd get the matching case.[/i]

[b]Guitar Strap[/b] - Cheap and (ahem?) unstylish.  Trust me.  I gave my 13 year old daughter the standard black strap and she just looked at me and asked if I was "for real".  Now she has a checkerboard one, one with cherries on it, and a purple lightning bolt one.  They're like shoes with girls.

[b]Pick Sampler[/b] - If I knew your address, I'd send you 5 different picks.  (No, I don't want your address, I'm just saying that)  Most music stores have picks with their logos on them for free.  Come to a PT show here in Dallas and I'll give you picks AND a free T-Shirt.  And again, these are like jewelry for girls.  They have to look good, too.
So, what I'm saying is if you're willing to spend that $200, spend it entirely on the gear she's going to need to use.

Another great company for US buyers is American Music Supply.  No, I do not work there.  But they offer "easy payment plans".  If you have a major Credit Card, you can "charge" up to $500 and break it down into three equal monthly payments, but get your gear immediately.

So, if you think you could spend a little more in the next couple of months, check them out.  Fast, free ground shipping, products arrive in 2-3 days.  That's where I got my daughter's A.L. Squier Tele.

www.americanmusicsupply.com
[QUOTE]

[b]Micrówave wrote: [/b]

The guitar seems ok, but just so you know about the items that come with it.  Guitar packages are designed for parents who think this is all they'll need to buy their spoiled little one.  Only then, have they sunken their claws into you...

Includes:
[b]Amplifier[/b] - Will be suitable for a bedroom, but any other use (rehearsal, live, etc.) would require a larger amp
[i]I say that because you'll be getting a 20 pound paper weight.  If you were to buy a small combo amp, it would be quite flexable and give years of use.  Plus you'd get much better re-sale value if you were looking to upgrade.  No, you can't Mic a 5 Watt amp and sound good.[/i]

[b]Guitar Stand [/b]- Suitable, but easily knocked over.  I would suggest a wall mount.  $10

[b]Instructional DVD[/b] - worthless, get lessons.  Might teach you to re-string and play a couple of chords, but so can my Aunt Rose.

[b]Cable[/b] - cheap, you'll be replacing it soon...
[i]They say an instrument is only as good as the cable that's plugged into it.  Worth an extra $10-15 to buy a good premium cable.  Most have lifetime warranties.

[/i][b]Electronic Tuner[/b] - Cheap, you'll be replacing it soon...
[i]Again, you're going to get a bottom of the barrel Quik Tune.  It's not backlit, only tunes a certain way, doesn't offer special settings, eats 9V batteries, etc.
[/i]
[b]Gig Bag[/b] - Gonna be a while until you really need one of these.  Unless you plan on just carrying it around just because you have a guitar.   [i]Again, if re-sale is a possibility, a hard shell case is better.  Even for a $200 guitar.  Gator (brand) makes a pretty decent one for $50, Squier's is around $60.  I'd get the matching case.[/i]

[b]Guitar Strap[/b] - Cheap and (ahem?) unstylish.  Trust me.  I gave my 13 year old daughter the standard black strap and she just looked at me and asked if I was "for real".  Now she has a checkerboard one, one with cherries on it, and a purple lightning bolt one.  They're like shoes with girls.

[b]Pick Sampler[/b] - If I knew your address, I'd send you 5 different picks.  (No, I don't want your address, I'm just saying that)  Most music stores have picks with their logos on them for free.  Come to a PT show here in Dallas and I'll give you picks AND a free T-Shirt.  And again, these are like jewelry for girls.  They have to look good, too.[/QUOTE]

Holy crap, that's a LOT of info! Thank you, thank you.

I was afraid the 'package' might be too good to be true but I had hope. I also now see why it's so important to shop for this in person. I'm going to need that personal attention since there are more questions to ask than I'd realized - though you've cleared up quite a few. Thanks again.
"The others don't like my interviews. And frankly, I don't care much for theirs." ~ Freddie Mercury
I had a Cherry red Squire Stratocaster with a humbucker at the bridge.....beautiful guitar. That was back in 93...unfortunately, it been about 7 different colours since and is now in bits under the stairs! I think i should put it back together, but if I was starting out again I'd definately go for the strat...a lot more versatile than the tele tonally so you can then make you mind up as to what you want to progress to. As for everything that goes with it....you can pick the lot up, amp included, for less than £100.......your amp doesnt need to be anything spectacular. Anything 10-20W will suffice, theres plenty of decent ones on the market. You can get decent Ernie Ball straps for about £5 and plectrums are about 50p each. I started with 1.2mm now play with 0.9mm. My lead cost me £20 in 1997 with a lifetime gaurantee and its still going strong after lots and lots of gigging.
Chom own mudder fukker.
[QUOTE]

[b]magicalfreddiemercury wrote: [/b]







 







ThomasQuinn wrote: 
"Now that's just a matter of opinion. If you play rockabilly, sure. If you play metal, not a chance. Every guitarist needs to find the guitar (and amp) to go with their own playing and preferred sound. Most guitars that are well constructed are quite suitable for learning to play, but the closer the sound is to what the guitarist in question needs, the longer it'll take before he/she outgrows his/her first guitar."

===

Think "Renegade" by Styx. She wants to play the guitar solo in that.She talks about it all the time. I'm guessing that's the 'sound' she wants.








 





[/QUOTE]
Tommy Shaw played the solo on that song, so that'd be a Les Paul-type guitar. However, more important than even the guitar in getting such a sound is an overdrive/distortion effect. The type built into amplifiers won't do for this kind of work. Shaw used a Boss OD-3, which costs around $80,-. A cheaper Boss DS-1 would make her just as happy, though, I think.

If you try playing this kind of rock on a stratocaster or other type of guitar that has single-coil pick-ups, you'd get enormous amounts of hiss, so I couldn't recommend buying a Strat-type if your daughter wants to play this kind of music, unless you're willing to buy her a noise gate pedal to go with it.
Not Plutus but Apollo rules Parnassus
[QUOTE]

 



[b]ThomasQuinn wrote: [/b]



 

[QUOTE]

 



[b]magicalfreddiemercury wrote: [/b]



 



ThomasQuinn wrote: 
"Now that's just a matter of opinion. If you play rockabilly, sure. If you play metal, not a chance. Every guitarist needs to find the guitar (and amp) to go with their own playing and preferred sound. Most guitars that are well constructed are quite suitable for learning to play, but the closer the sound is to what the guitarist in question needs, the longer it'll take before he/she outgrows his/her first guitar."

===

Think "Renegade" by Styx. She wants to play the guitar solo in that.She talks about it all the time. I'm guessing that's the 'sound' she wants.  



 

[/QUOTE]
Tommy Shaw played the solo on that song, so that'd be a Les Paul-type guitar. However, more important than even the guitar in getting such a sound is an overdrive/distortion effect. The type built into amplifiers won't do for this kind of work. Shaw used a Boss OD-3, which costs around $80,-. A cheaper Boss DS-1 would make her just as happy, though, I think.

If you try playing this kind of rock on a stratocaster or other type of guitar that has single-coil pick-ups, you'd get enormous amounts of hiss, so I couldn't recommend buying a Strat-type if your daughter wants to play this kind of music, unless you're willing to buy her a noise gate pedal to go with it.


[/QUOTE]
Well... I'd rather not buy more than I need to buy upfront. So I wonder... would she even notice this hiss? She's never played before so maybe, I'm guessing here, she could start learning on the type of guitar Microwave suggested and then, as she progresses, I can add what she needs for better or fuller sounds.  ???
"The others don't like my interviews. And frankly, I don't care much for theirs." ~ Freddie Mercury
If she seriously wants to learn to play the guitar well, she'll need to start taking lessons in both theory and guitar technique, and to take them quite seriously. As far as gear is concerned, for someone learning to play the most important thing is to buy an amplifier that sounds good. I suggest, for the best compromise between budget, sound quality and your and your neighbors ears, an amp between 15-30 watts. Have the vendor demonstrate the guitar you are going to buy to a number of amps, and choose the one you like best. Things to look for:

- Equalizer must be three band (a separate knob for low, mid and high),
- There must be a clean and an overdrive (also called 'dirty' or 'crunch' on some amps), noticeable by a "gain" or "crunch" know.
- I'd give preference to an amp that also has a Reverb included.

The most ideal scenario for the guitar if you are going to use it for serious study is to use a guitar that has long sustain (meaning the time a sound is audible is quite long), and preferably at least one humbucker and one single coil pick-up.

http://www.igdb.co.uk/pages/beginners/images/sc_and_h.jpg

The ones on the outside are humbuckers, the one in the middle is a single coil.

I can highly recommend buying a Yamaha guitar, and most guitar teachers I know give preference to them for student guitars.
Not Plutus but Apollo rules Parnassus
Get her the cheapest guitar you can find. If she can make it sound good, then you'll know she's got at least some talent.
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Jake? wrote: I want him to shove it down my throat and shoot. Shoot! Shoot! C'mon! SHOOT! SHOOT! [/QUOTENAME] [/QUOTE]
It was Christmas 1994.

I wanted a teddy bear.

My parents bought me pajama instead.

I cried.

They never found out.

Sad times.
I'm sick of all my kicks.
[QUOTE]

 



[b]ThomasQuinn wrote: [/b]



If she seriously wants to learn to play the guitar well, she'll need to start taking lessons in both theory and guitar technique, and to take them quite seriously. As far as gear is concerned, for someone learning to play the most important thing is to buy an amplifier that sounds good. I suggest, for the best compromise between budget, sound quality and your and your neighbors ears, an amp between 15-30 watts. Have the vendor demonstrate the guitar you are going to buy to a number of amps, and choose the one you like best. Things to look for:

- Equalizer must be three band (a separate knob for low, mid and high),
- There must be a clean and an overdrive (also called 'dirty' or 'crunch' on some amps), noticeable by a "gain" or "crunch" know.
- I'd give preference to an amp that also has a Reverb included.

The most ideal scenario for the guitar if you are going to use it for serious study is to use a guitar that has long sustain (meaning the time a sound is audible is quite long), and preferably at least one humbucker and one single coil pick-up.

http://www.igdb.co.uk/pages/beginners/images/sc_and_h.jpg

The ones on the outside are humbuckers, the one in the middle is a single coil.

I can highly recommend buying a Yamaha guitar, and most guitar teachers I know give preference to them for student guitars.

[/QUOTE]

This was like a mini-lesson. Thanks so much!
"The others don't like my interviews. And frankly, I don't care much for theirs." ~ Freddie Mercury
[QUOTE]

[b]Poo, again wrote: [/b]

Get her the cheapest guitar you can find. If she can make it sound good, then you'll know she's got at least some talent. [/QUOTE]

You know, for a while there, this is what I was thinking. But... if I'm going to spend the money, I want it to be on something of quality so she can get a true sense of what it's like to play.



There's a lot of info here in this thread, and I have to sort through it all, but at least I have direction now. My thanks to all of you, you've been a great help.
"The others don't like my interviews. And frankly, I don't care much for theirs." ~ Freddie Mercury