Queen crest Queenzone

Similarities Between Roger Solo Work and Pink Floyd?

9 posts
Thread

Posts in chronological order

· Member since
Was listening to Pink Floyd's live "Pulse" album, and it suddenly dawned on me just how similar some of Roger's Solo work, or even that of The Cross, is to some of the later Floyd work.  Having got to "What Do You Want From Me" and "Learn To Fly", I could soon hear segments from tracks such as "Power To Love" or "The Key" popping into my head, as well as stuff from Fun In Space, as though both artists were merging.  I swear I'm not on anything, and I'm defo not tripping - I reckon if I delve deeper into this, I'll find more.  Has anyone else experienced this or thought like this?  Any answers are welcomed, even if they are to tell me to stop talking shit!
· Member since
TBBH, the only clear similarity I notice is that lyrics are in English. Other than that, there are loads of artists who are more similar to either.
John hated Hot Space. Frederick's favourite singer was not Paul Rodgers. Roger didn't compose 'Innuendo.' 'Bohemian Rhapsody' hasn't got 180 vocal overdubs.
· Member since
Listen to "amused to death" (album) by R. Waters..

The backing vocals work (specially the female..) sounds a lot like the ones in "Happiness?".
Queen rocks!
· Member since
I actually thought that myself when I first listened to the Happiness album in 1994.  The whole disc has a backing atmosphere that is very Floydish...
· Member since
I actually thought that myself when I first listened to the Happiness album in 1994.  The whole disc has a backing atmosphere that is very Floydish...
· Member since
Yes. Same atmosphere
· Member since
Don't forget Roger employed Hipgnosis (who did most of the classic Pink Floyd album covers) to do the cover for Fun In Space (I still love the artwork and the different comic designs that were on the inner sleeve and the picture labels that were on the original US vinyl record.

My Country, Laugh or Cry, Magic is Loose and the title cut to Fun in Space sounds like Roger journeyed to "The Dark Side of the Moon" and was listening also to Wish You Were Here and Animals and The Wall at the time of recording Fun In Space. Even some of Electric Fire had some Floydian influences.
"Spread your wings and fly away, fly away, far away!", "No one makes me sing lullabies and no one makes me close my eyes"
· Member since
Not realy a comparisison between Roger Taylor and Roger Waters (Pink Floyd). Waters is an absolute genius, great songwriter. Roger Taylor i.m.h.o. is a drummer with average song writing capacities. The 4 members are Queen, Roger Waters is Floyd.
· Member since
whynot wrote: Not realy a comparisison between Roger Taylor and Roger Waters (Pink Floyd). Waters is an absolute genius, great songwriter. Roger Taylor i.m.h.o. is a drummer with average song writing capacities. The 4 members are Queen, Roger Waters is Floyd. =============================================================================================

I think you kinda missed the point there!  The question is about the sounds they have put out, not about who is the more talented.  Also, I beg to differ RE your statement that Waters is Floyd - that would be Gilmour!!!