Sticking up for brianswig and the Fanthology group

I think it's wrong to point or complain about the folks within this special group who are working hard to make a large collection of Queen (and related) output. I'm not a member of this group but i do apreciate what they're doing. And then people come on here sticking their pins and complaining because all they want are the rare tracks some people paid big bucks for it.

Thanks a lot for sharing this. I really love the raw sound of early Queen.

But i do have a question.

Are you sure that this is before Freddie laid the main vocal down? I allways thought that guide vocal was donne by Brian, but even if it was Freddie, this vocals are buried down in the mix but it still sounds like the final vocals to me. I know it´s not clear, but at least in the places where we can hear, the metric and pitch of the words sounds like the final vocals to me.

This sounds like the original edit to me, so i´m really not sure what i´m missing here. Maybe you or others can clarify this for me.

--------------------------
---------------------------

On the subject of sharing, i really appreciate that you and others are able to share some incredible stuff here. I really loved the Freddie and Cliff track you´ve share here last month.

This is just someone pissing about with the multitrack, surely you can hear that?! Its bullshit.

This excact my thought also Moog, I think it's fake and that it got little to do with John.....

I think this is a fake, too. Didn't want to hijack the thread, though.

Faker than fake. Bad editing, awkward as shit echoes, and all.

I got this from someone who told me that it was genuine. Well thanks to you guys i know that's it's a double fake. We can close this post now and i will delete it. My opinion about the fanthology though stays. Thanks for your replies. I'm not the person who wants to share fakes so i don't like this at all.

I hope you didn't trade for that...

[QUOTE] [b]dave76 wrote:[/b]

I got this from someone who told me that it was genuine. [/QUOTE]

Well ... of course! What are they gonna say to you: 'hey, this is fake!'?

no i didn't trade for it. i've just sent this guy some rare tracks from some other artists. i did that free of will.
well, then i guess that the "a winter's tale" final take which i also received from is another fake. it has some studio banter at the end,

[QUOTE] [b]dave76 wrote:[/b]

no i didn't trade for it. i've just sent this guy some rare tracks from some other artists. i did that free of will.
well, then i guess that the "a winter's tale" final take which i also received from is another fake. it has some studio banter at the end,[/QUOTE]

What is said in the studio banter? It may have come from other source. Silver Salmon and Polar Bear have some studio banter for example

Sorry dave76, I hope you didn't feel you were being hounded. Is "A Winter's Tale" something you'd be willing to share? If it's real, then great stuff and if it's fake, at least you'd know.

[QUOTE] [b]dave76 wrote:[/b]

I got this from someone who told me that it was genuine.[/QUOTE]

Unicorns exist. It must be true because I just told you.

^ they do actually Moog. I've seen 'em. My mate said it was a horse with an ice-cream cone, but I didn't believe him.

[QUOTE] [b]dave76 wrote:[/b]

I think it's wrong to point or complain about the folks within this special group who are working hard to make a large collection of Queen (and related) output.
[/QUOTE]

Making stuff up and pretending it is something it isn't? Fuck them.