SweetCaroline wrote: taptap wrote:
Okay, personally I think of this sort of thing as pseudo-psychology at best, but at the same time I think this guy is dead on right about Adam, in whatever terms he uses. I think it explains the sort of hyper response he often gets from people who have seen him live. When he sang the Bowie medley during the AI tour after his season, I thought this whole concept of masculinity and femininity in balance was really strongly on display. Of course with Adam's 'new-age hippy' personality, I imagine this stuff is right up his alley, next to astrological charting and all.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6mcQXVlAyK4
Here's the Bowie medley:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GwgUq7ZeQNs
Wow, where did you find that analysis of Adam's masculine/feminine energy? Explains a lot about his attraction to both men and women and I like the mention to Elvis which I noticed immediately the first time I saw him.
Not exactly related to your post, but I haven't seen this amazing live performance of "Whataya Want From Me" posted previously. A very good example of that energy, charisma and stage presence that has the audience going crazy!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=88H30tsnSmA
Caroline, there's an interesting discussion about the whole sexual energy analysis thing on another site. The part I think is interesting is the theory that this strong yin and yang balance (integrated feminine and masculine traits) is what makes him a polarizing figure. That not only this balance, but his comfort with it, exudes a high level of confidence, and people tend to see that in one of two ways. Either they admire that confidence, and love him, or they see it as arrogance and/or a lack of humility, and don't like him at all.
This makes a lot of sense to me. And it really works for the American Idol demographic as it has devolved over the last five years as well. A lot of those people are older, less educated, and poor, which, in my experience goes hand-in-hand with low self-esteem, and a distrust of those with high self-esteem. It doesn't mean he has any more or less fans that any other artist, it just means that his fans and anti-fans generally have a much stronger emotional response to him.
Whether the cause and effect logic is valid, the result is pretty plain to see. Love him or hate him, people can't stop talking about him. Of course Brian and Roger probably love this aspect of Adam, because it's sure helping a lot with the summer tour sales.