https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XqLTe8h0-jo
about 1.22 in
Best try not see the rest of it.
dysan
Thread
Posts in chronological order
Rick
Brian Wilson _O_
A Word In Your Ear
Behind the scenes.....Brian talks and plays guitar
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vp5bVdXOLs4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vp5bVdXOLs4
The Real Wizard
HAHAHA !!! Hundreds of Vox AC30s all called MAYs !!!!!
inu-liger
That was really good :)
Bohardy
That was not really good.
Why on earth, after the 4 bar intro, does the 5th bar start early and proceed at a quicker tempo to the intro? That's absolutely hideous, and I cannot understand how the dozens of professional musicians and producers that heard this prior to it being finalised/released did not notice that. The only explanation is that it is intentional, but then, it's so jarring and ghastly that I cannot believe it is intentional.
It makes no sense.
Aside from that, this is just typical of these charity ensemble cover things; the production ensures the song loses all charm, subtlety, and emotion that it originally had.
Why on earth, after the 4 bar intro, does the 5th bar start early and proceed at a quicker tempo to the intro? That's absolutely hideous, and I cannot understand how the dozens of professional musicians and producers that heard this prior to it being finalised/released did not notice that. The only explanation is that it is intentional, but then, it's so jarring and ghastly that I cannot believe it is intentional.
It makes no sense.
Aside from that, this is just typical of these charity ensemble cover things; the production ensures the song loses all charm, subtlety, and emotion that it originally had.
inu-liger
[QUOTE] [b]Bohardy wrote:[/b]
Why on earth, after the 4 bar intro, does the 5th bar start early and proceed at a quicker tempo to the intro? That's absolutely hideous, and I cannot understand how the dozens of professional musicians and producers that heard this prior to it being finalised/released did not notice that. The only explanation is that it is intentional, but then, it's so jarring and ghastly that I cannot believe it is intentional.
It makes no sense. [/QUOTE]
Well it IS Brian Wilson's song and the man himself is on the whole recording, and ultimately it had to have been up to him if he had an issue with the bar + tempo change which evidently he doesn't appear to have had.
Why on earth, after the 4 bar intro, does the 5th bar start early and proceed at a quicker tempo to the intro? That's absolutely hideous, and I cannot understand how the dozens of professional musicians and producers that heard this prior to it being finalised/released did not notice that. The only explanation is that it is intentional, but then, it's so jarring and ghastly that I cannot believe it is intentional.
It makes no sense. [/QUOTE]
Well it IS Brian Wilson's song and the man himself is on the whole recording, and ultimately it had to have been up to him if he had an issue with the bar + tempo change which evidently he doesn't appear to have had.
Bohardy
I doubt he had that much of a say over the final mix. He wasn't the producer.
But, even if he did have a say, my point still remains: why would anyone want an intro that's out of time with the rest of the song, in a totally unmusical way?
Perhaps it's a glitch on the YouTube video or something. That's a more understandable explanation.
But, even if he did have a say, my point still remains: why would anyone want an intro that's out of time with the rest of the song, in a totally unmusical way?
Perhaps it's a glitch on the YouTube video or something. That's a more understandable explanation.
inu-liger
Hmm, listening to the intro again, I think the bigger issue is the flutes come in significantly delayed on the first beat of the 4th bar, which *makes* it seem like the 5th bar is much too early.
Bad Seed
It's a bloody edited advert, not the whole song!
inu-liger
Oh?
Bad Seed
Actually I hope I am correct! But apparently this version is just an advertisement for BBC Music, a full single version will be released for BBC Children in need.
Bad Seed
Hmmmm maybe this is the full version??? Hope not!
Togg
It's no different to the original, go listen again... jeez
anniestu44b
Wow, some things get taken far too seriously lol