I think you misread her post, Icy. The point was that Freddie wrote that music and had that interaction in that way with the audience. Now Freddie is no longer here, but that same interaction still takes place because of Freddie. He so touched lives that someone else can sing it and folks still respond in the way they did for Freddie. Freddie lives through the music.
Icy, you sound so resentful towards Adam for no good reason. Freddie isn't here to sing that song and it has gone away if no one is singing Gaga and continuing the tradition. Adam brought it back because he sings for QAL and that is one of their signature songs. I have never seen Freddie in concert singing this live, so I have no comparison in my mind. Adam does an amazing job with it and moved the audience to respond in the way they always had. You could just feel the love in the audience when this song is performed. I would say that it was a job well done. Adam isn't playing a part. He isn't Freddie, doesn't need to be Freddie and doesn't want to be Freddie and he carries this off being Adam, who most people who go to the concert are very pleased with. The concerts would not be sold out already if people didn't like the way Adam sang with Queen. Just playing the music with an average singer/frontman will not guarantee a full house just because it is Queen's music. PR didn't sell shows out and had pretty mediocre reviews. There was a reason they quit touring. It is a full house now at the QAL concerts because Brian, Roger, and Adam put on a kick ass show. Too many people go to multiple shows during multiple tours and they are not thinking, "Wow, this isn't Freddie" like you. They go because they love the show in its present configuration. People don't pay the kind of money it costs for tickets to attend a concert they don't really enjoy. It just doesn't work that way. You have to conclude that Adam does a great job and people are happy to watch him perform with Queen. Everyone I have talked to in person who was at a QAL show has been effusive about the performance of Roger, Brian and Adam. I haven't talked to one person at any of the shows who didn't think it was awesome. I know you don't want to give Adam any credit, but they wouldn't be selling out with any other singer, IMO.
There are people who think by watching the trailer of the Bohemian Rhapsody movie, they can judge the whole movie and there are people who think by watching a YouTube clip of a QAL concert, they can judge the whole show as if they are physically there in that arena or outdoor venue surrounded by the magic of the spectacular sound and lights!
Of course, I am sure people go to see Brian and Roger. I do, too! But they couldn't carry off the show on their own anymore. It is impossible for them to play and sing and do everything. It is amazing that they can do what they do, esp. Brian. How he manages to sing and do all that amazing guitar playing at his age is a puzzler to me. A lot of young people couldn't carry that off. But many, many people go because with the three of them, it just works.
I am not sure why you keep bringing up that it isn't Adam's music. At this point, so what? If you can sing the songs and carry them off and people are more than happy, why does that affect anything? Tons of people all around the world sing music that they didn't write or weren't the first to perform. That is not a non starter for many people. On Broadway they change stars and singers all the time. People don't say, "Well, So and So was the first to sing this part, now I am not going because someone else is". I personally find that kind of silly. You go and either enjoy the show as it currently is or you stay home. Some of it is Broadway, but there are still plenty of rock elements. Brian isn't playing broadway, trust me. The show is divided into segments and covers different genres of music with different costumes, background elements and it is really neat the way the show is configured. As I always say, It just works!
As far as QPR, you are one of the few (and mostly they are die hard Queen fans) who say that QPR kicked ass. I have read tons of comments and reviews and that is not the general consensus. Everybody likes something different, but you really work hard at denigrating everything Adam does. I don't get it. You always have reasons why he is not worthy, if you want to put it that way. We will just agree to differ on that one.
Of course, I am sure people go to see Brian and Roger. I do, too! But they couldn't carry off the show on their own anymore. It is impossible for them to play and sing and do everything. It is amazing that they can do what they do, esp. Brian. How he manages to sing and do all that amazing guitar playing at his age is a puzzler to me. A lot of young people couldn't carry that off. But many, many people go because with the three of them, it just works.
I am not sure why you keep bringing up that it isn't Adam's music. At this point, so what? If you can sing the songs and carry them off and people are more than happy, why does that affect anything? Tons of people all around the world sing music that they didn't write or weren't the first to perform. That is not a non starter for many people. On Broadway they change stars and singers all the time. People don't say, "Well, So and So was the first to sing this part, now I am not going because someone else is". I personally find that kind of silly. You go and either enjoy the show as it currently is or you stay home. Some of it is Broadway, but there are still plenty of rock elements. Brian isn't playing broadway, trust me. The show is divided into segments and covers different genres of music with different costumes, background elements and it is really neat the way the show is configured. As I always say, It just works!
As far as QPR, you are one of the few (and mostly they are die hard Queen fans) who say that QPR kicked ass. I have read tons of comments and reviews and that is not the general consensus. Everybody likes something different, but you really work hard at denigrating everything Adam does. I don't get it. You always have reasons why he is not worthy, if you want to put it that way. We will just agree to differ on that one.
The war has started on SweetCaroline!
Killjoy, happy Valentine’s Day to you, too!
That was wonderful, one of my favorite songs! I do so wish it would be included in the Rhapsody tour. Phillip Storey should check this youtube out and see how uninterested the audience seems and how they are all sitting on their hands and totally bored. Right! Adam's voice and personality are infectious and the audience is always enthralled when he sings. People don't attend concerts if that is not the case.
Phillip might also notice all the SWEATING in this one, too!! Although I find that a ridiculous thing to rate a performance on!
