Roger or Brian- who's a better singer?

I prefer Roger as a backing singer to the Queen songs (especially live)because it's more distinct, adds more to the "complete" sound. On the non-Freddie Queen studio songs I also prefer Roger.
On solo songs, Brian is the better singer I think. He picks songs that fit better to his voice then Roger does.

Roger

Roger all the way. His backing singing complemented Freddie perfectly live. Brian's voice is very weak - he usually does a reasonble job but Roger buries him.

JG

brian is not a very good singer...on the studio version of who wants to live he sounds dreadfully out of tune in a few parts.

Roger is better. He's got such a strong voice with characteristic hoarseness. I like Brian's songs but I don't like his singing. I just can't get used to it.

Roger's a very good singer. And I also think he has the best solo carreer. I mean Happiness? is in my top 5 under Led Zeppelin 4.

Roger has a much stronger voice and I like his voice more.

Mix them together with a 1 Freddie Mercury bliss

I think there`s no "good singer" or "better singer"... both are great, is just that BM and RT have very different voices and songs...

I love Brian´s voice... just listen Too Much Love... of BacktoTheLight, and his voice makes me cry...On the other hand, Roger has a... I don't know.. he can take really high notes, and that just makes me nuts.

bye!

I like them both equally but for different reasons.
Brian is a nice singer, very smooth voice and Roger is really raspy, v. v. sexy !!!!!!!

i personally think that Brian is a better singer.
(Roger always sounds like he has a sore throat.)

Ever wondered why this guy called Freddie Mercury was their lead singer?!

Roger. It is almost as important to the Queen vocal sound as Freddie! Imagine Radio GaGa in the Magic tour without Roger's voice. And many more examples ....

Roger. Brian has a very weak voice, although he's not bad on ballads. I wish Freddie sang "Driven By You" - it would be so much better!

Roger :)