Polar bear

What do you think of freddies version of this song???

much better than brians.

BRIAN DIDN'T HAVE A VERSION OF IT ONLY TIM... AND I BELIEVE SOME OTHER BRITISH BAND WHO DID NOT MAKE MUCH FURIA WITH THE PUBLIC DID TRY TO COVER IT... BUT YES TO ME FREDDIES VERSION IS NICER TO HEAR THAN DARLING TIM.... I DO QUITE LIKE THE WAY FREDDIE CHANGED THE VOICES WITHIN THE SONG

[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]the_hero wrote: [/QUOTENAME]Brian sang the first verse of the Smile version.[/QUOTE]I do have that version, but it doesn't sound much like Brian to me...

I love when Tim lets lose at the end of the last verse, it's almost comical but you can tell he's got some 'soul'.

Tim has assured me that it's Brian singing the verses. The middle part was indeed sung by Tim, who is still trying to forget.

Calling it "soulful" is just about the most friendly thing one can say about that part......

Tim always did say that Smile was a pretty "sloppy" band. But I do have to say I like Freddie's more because he has more vocal training than Tim or Brian at the time or whoever was singing (and for those who are like me, you'll know that Freddie's vocal training, with the exception of his recording with Montserrat, was slim to nil).

Tim is a good singer .. saw some solo work and it's pritty good, but sounds very individual and that's maybe one of the reasons that it didn't work within smile...

I like Tim's version more than Freddie's, but love Doin' Alright by Freddie more than Tim's.

I prefer Tims "April Lady"

[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]<font color=red>BEE<font color=gold>ny wrote: [/QUOTENAME]I prefer Tims "April Lady"[/QUOTE]

I prefer Roger's BVs on it

I prefer Brian on vocals

I prefer Smile version...

both versions suck

[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Fenderek wrote: [/QUOTENAME]I prefer Smile version...[/QUOTE]Sorry that's what I ment....


NOthing suck, meaning that it's not a fact but ----just your opinion !!!