what queen would be like if freddie didn't replaced tim??

Will queen be a legend like they do with freddie???

Brian has a great talent on the guitar and he wrote great songs too, roger is great on the drum but not very good in writing songs and john is really quite but he playing the bass quite good and wrote some big hits...well i don't really know about tim talents...but absolutely i don't think he is better than freddie...

I wouldn't know much about Tim's voice, since I only heard the contents on "In Nuce". I must say though, his vocal range is nice...His vocal work on the song Polar Bear is great. But I have to say, when it goes on to the main chorus, or whatever, he exaggerates, and starts either singing off key, or having trouble with it. Freddie, without a question is a MUCH BETTER lead singer than Tim. But...getting on topic now...In my opinion, if they ever were to become famous, Brian would be the one keeping the band alive. So would Roger, and John. I have to disagree with you though. I think Roger's composition skills are excellent. But That is just my opinion. I am no expert, of course...so If I am wrong, correct me. :)

I'll correct you!...Roger had some problems in the writing department in my opinion. I'm talking early queen, usually he wrote one song per album in the early days and usually they were the least best on the album. "loser in the end, drowse, more of that jazz, coming soon. remember, if it wasn't for bo rhap they would have probably broke up. to answer your question, queen wouldn't have made it without freddie. freddie wouldn't have made it without the others either. they needed each other. Time was running out for them, they were already in their mid to late twenties when they released their first album.

[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Zhavie wrote: [/QUOTENAME]Will queen be a legend like they do with freddie???

Brian has a great talent on the guitar and he wrote great songs too, roger is great on the drum but not very good in writing songs and john is really quite but he playing the bass quite good and wrote some big hits...well i don't really know about tim talents...but absolutely i don't think he is better than freddie...

[/QUOTE]

Genius, they were gonna break up plus they wouldnt be Queen because Freddie thought of that name. I mean these what ifs are starting to scrape the bottom of the barrell and teter on stupid ad inane..

There wouldn't be Queen if Freddie didn't replace Tim

[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]<font color="Pink">The Show Must Go On wrote: [/QUOTENAME]There wouldn't be Queen if Freddie didn't replace Tim[/QUOTE]
Exactly

[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Zhavie wrote: [/QUOTENAME]Will queen be a legend like they do with freddie???

Brian has a great talent on the guitar and he wrote great songs too, roger is great on the drum but not very good in writing songs and john is really quite but he playing the bass quite good and wrote some big hits...well i don't really know about tim talents...but absolutely i don't think he is better than freddie...

[/QUOTE]


I think I might have to kill you for saying that Roger cant write songs......
He deffenetely wrote a lot of crap, but most of the songs that made it to the albums are really brilliant!
How can you critisise stuff like TATDOOL or Modern Times Rock/Roll, or Radio GaGa????

He could write songs, in the later days he became a solid songwriter. the writing in the early days wasn't so good. I'm in love with my car is ok, and tenament funster rules. I'll say half the songs he wrote were crap and half were good or great. I don't consider radio ga ga one of queens best songs and I like johns songwriting above rogers.

[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]M a t i a s M a y<h6><i>QZ's Rainmaker wrote: [/QUOTENAME][QUOTE][QUOTENAME]<font color="Pink">The Show Must Go On wrote: [/QUOTENAME]There wouldn't be Queen if Freddie didn't replace Tim[/QUOTE]
Exactly[/QUOTE]

no only that, but there wouldn't be a Queen legacy.

i am not saying that roger is bad at writing song but he is just not as good as freddie, brian and even john...he only wrote some big hits unlike the others i think...

without Freddie,Mr May and Mr Taylor would be great ditch diggers.

[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Zhavie wrote: [/QUOTENAME]i am not saying that roger is bad at writing song but he is just not as good as freddie, brian and even john...he only wrote some big hits unlike the others i think...[/QUOTE]

Objectively speaking, Roger had more capabilities than John. John was a thorougly mediocre composer.

What if John had a beard? Then he would be someone with a beard. Nice topic.

I spoke to Tim some years ago in London and he said that he could never have done what Freddie did for Queen and that he had no regrets (and he said it was nice to still receive two cheques a year for his songwriting contribution to Doin' Alright ... - oh and he said that his favourite Queen song was probably Somebody To Love)
Anyway, Tim's a real nice guy!

Cheers, Mike

Obviously there would be no Queen as they were still known as Smile in the early days. But i must point out that Freddie actually wrote most of the Queen songs that became hits in most of the world, even the harder rock tracks that most ppl think that it was Brian. And John, lol he copied most of his arrangements, Another one bites the dust (Good Times), Spread your wings (Rocky Raccoon). Tim is an ok singer, has a good range, but no Freddie, but who is? Freddie! I think Smile would have had more success than they had, but not even close to Queen's.