Who was the best Songwriter in the group?

freddie, john, brian, roger

Meh. I prefer Tim Staffel.

[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Sebastian wrote: [/QUOTENAME]I vote for all four of them, they were all brilliant.[/QUOTE]




I agree

[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]M a t i a s M a y<h6><i>QZ's Rainmaker wrote: [/QUOTENAME]Apollo Creed[/QUOTE]

wtf?? LMAO! ;D

I think it's:

Freddie
Brian
John
Roger

then again it's soooo hard to say!!! I love all of their songs equally, it's just that Freddie and Brian have waaaaaaaayyyyy more songs individually than Roger and John combined! (okay maybe I'm exaggerating a bit)

Freddie once said that although Brian wrote the most songs, Freddie always had the high placing songs, and I suppose that sounds like he is bragging but it is kinda true. But I think they are all talented it their our rights. It is too hard to choose.

1. freddie
2. brian
3. john
4. roger

Generally they were all pretty good, even Rog. Freddie is sometimes underestimated as a composer. Most often he is described as a great showman, but not many people talk about him as a great songwriter as well.

[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]paul o brien wrote: [/QUOTENAME][QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Sebastian wrote: [/QUOTENAME]I vote for all four of them, they were all brilliant.[/QUOTE]




I agree[/QUOTE]


I second that.

Freddie wrote the best songs but his powers declined before rising again. Brian was the most consistently good.

Freddie

brian
freddie
roger
john

Roger and Freddie did a flip-flop ...

Pre-Flash:

1. Freddie
2. Brian
3. John
4. Roger

Post-Flash:

1. Roger
2. Brian
3. John
4. Freddie

I recall Jim Jenkins saying to Freddie:

Maybe now that you've shaved off your mustache maybe you can write a decent song for a change

1.FREDDIE
2.ROGER
3.BRIAN
4.JOHN

1. Paul
2. Roger
3. John
4. Paul
5. Paul Simon

They all were great songwriters but most of Roger's best stuff wasnt written for Queen.....his solo stuff is great.

Freddie
Brian
John
Roger