Maybe the footage from Knebworth (except that from the big screen) doesn't exist, but it would certainly make a nice double-disc release one day.
Thread
Posts in chronological order
Brian said the video footage doesn't exist. But some or all of the audio seems to be in the vault, as some songs on Live Magic are from Knebworth (the others are from Wembley and Nepstadion, according to the sleeve). And in '99 they issued the aforementioned "Knebworth Mix" of "Under Pressure".
And SirGH, I listened to the two audience participation pieces again (Live Magic's and the Knebworth Mix's) and except for the last few seconds and Freddie's dialogue, the two are different. Not subtly different, but he's singing entirely different melodies.
Compare the two. Someone's been doing some editing somewhere.
And SirGH, I listened to the two audience participation pieces again (Live Magic's and the Knebworth Mix's) and except for the last few seconds and Freddie's dialogue, the two are different. Not subtly different, but he's singing entirely different melodies.
Compare the two. Someone's been doing some editing somewhere.
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Sir GH<br><h6>ah yeah</h6> wrote: [/QUOTENAME][QUOTE][QUOTENAME]rhyeking wrote: [/QUOTENAME]And a footnote about the "Dayoos": the audience participation bit seems tobe culled from two or all three concerts featured on the album. The last part is definately from Knebworth ("you f---ers are good, I tell you!") and it sounds like at least one part in the middle is from Wembley.[/QUOTE]
Are you talking about the cd or LP here? On the cd, it's definitely all from Knebworth.[/QUOTE]
No, hammer to fall is from wembley 2nd night. I know that guitar solo in the middle out of thousands. Wembley...yep!!
Are you talking about the cd or LP here? On the cd, it's definitely all from Knebworth.[/QUOTE]
No, hammer to fall is from wembley 2nd night. I know that guitar solo in the middle out of thousands. Wembley...yep!!
The "ImportantIssueZone.com"! That was funny as hell Lester Burnham!
Yes, "Hammer To Fall" is from Wembley. I think SirGH is refering to the entire audience participation bit being from the Knebworth.
Rhyeking
Rhyeking
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Markman38 wrote: [/QUOTENAME]I'm not here to judge you, and if you make your life worthwhile by finding the truth about the publishing of Queen music I hope you are happy with that. But this was just a cose for me to sit back and smile from ear to ear.[/QUOTE]
Then you should have left it at that, rather than going out of your way to make fun of him for doing what you were too lazy to do.
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Lester Burnham wrote: [/QUOTENAME]For what it's worth, rhyeking, I found the information useful, and I thank you for that. I always enjoy hearing busted myths and so-called truths about Queen's history.[/QUOTE]
I'll second that.
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]rhyeking wrote: [/QUOTENAME]I think SirGH is refering to the entire audience participation bit being from the Knebworth.[/QUOTE]
Exactly, but on Live Magic, there is a cut in the middle. The Day-O on the Under Pressure Rah Mix cd single is also from Knebworth, and it starts at a point that was cut out from the Live Magic version. That's why the two appear to be different... but take my word for it... it's all Knebworth.
Then you should have left it at that, rather than going out of your way to make fun of him for doing what you were too lazy to do.
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Lester Burnham wrote: [/QUOTENAME]For what it's worth, rhyeking, I found the information useful, and I thank you for that. I always enjoy hearing busted myths and so-called truths about Queen's history.[/QUOTE]
I'll second that.
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]rhyeking wrote: [/QUOTENAME]I think SirGH is refering to the entire audience participation bit being from the Knebworth.[/QUOTE]
Exactly, but on Live Magic, there is a cut in the middle. The Day-O on the Under Pressure Rah Mix cd single is also from Knebworth, and it starts at a point that was cut out from the Live Magic version. That's why the two appear to be different... but take my word for it... it's all Knebworth.
Which vinyl pressing did you acquire? Mine is definetely edited (but, as you have said, not always in the music)! I should also notice that some CD pressings (e.g: the original Japanese pressing and also the 1994 re-issue to go along the Digital Master Series) are edited as vinyl (wrong master).
He Sir GH back off by calling me lazy, there is no point in interrupting this thing between Lester and me while there was no thing at all only a misunderstanding and a mutual mis interception about the humor he and I use. You at the other hand has nothing to do with this so your judgement is not cool and I rather have you to stay out of this..thanks in advance
This has to be one of the most mind-numbingly pointless posts I have ever come across. The real thing we should be discussing is the dreadful effects those edits had on the quality of the CD. That's what matters to the average Queen fan.
No... Not AGAIN!?
Well I make no apologies- I think it is an unneccessary topic- as I've said before we should be more concerned about the effects the edits had, we should discuss the quality of recording, singing etc. not something like this.
rhyeking wrote:
I think SirGH is refering to the entire audience participation bit being from the Knebworth.
SirGH wrote:
Exactly, but on Live Magic, there is a cut in the middle. The Day-O on the Under Pressure Rah Mix cd single is also from Knebworth, and it starts at a point that was cut out from the Live Magic version. That's why the two appear to be different... but take my word for it... it's all Knebworth.
And Rhyeking's reply:
Ah, okay. Thank you, SirGh. I knew there'd been some snipping done somewhere AND that the two appeared different. That explains it.
And as to this being pointless. I disagree, and so it would seem Lester and SirGH (among others) disagree. Serious Discussion should not be limited to subjective things like how a remix/edit/extension effects the listeability of a track. That is certainly a valid point of discussion and I welcome such discussions. But for collectors interested in having these alternate versions, mislabelling and misleading descriptions are very serious as it can effect the relative value of a rare release and for completists (such as me) who just want to have every version of everything Queen released, it's important to know what is out there.
Someone above asked what edition I have of the Live Magic LP. Mine is the Capitol Records pressing. Please don't tell me there's a difference between the UK and US editions.
To re-iterate, my research so far demonstrates there is no difference between the audio of the LP and CD, with the exception of the edited "Dayooo" audience participation bit. AND that the listed LP track times are wrong (the songs aren't edited on the LP).
I've presented the facts I've discovered and invited further discussion, unless we've covered everything.
Does anyone know what's going on on the cassette version? Was this released on cassette?
I think SirGH is refering to the entire audience participation bit being from the Knebworth.
SirGH wrote:
Exactly, but on Live Magic, there is a cut in the middle. The Day-O on the Under Pressure Rah Mix cd single is also from Knebworth, and it starts at a point that was cut out from the Live Magic version. That's why the two appear to be different... but take my word for it... it's all Knebworth.
And Rhyeking's reply:
Ah, okay. Thank you, SirGh. I knew there'd been some snipping done somewhere AND that the two appeared different. That explains it.
And as to this being pointless. I disagree, and so it would seem Lester and SirGH (among others) disagree. Serious Discussion should not be limited to subjective things like how a remix/edit/extension effects the listeability of a track. That is certainly a valid point of discussion and I welcome such discussions. But for collectors interested in having these alternate versions, mislabelling and misleading descriptions are very serious as it can effect the relative value of a rare release and for completists (such as me) who just want to have every version of everything Queen released, it's important to know what is out there.
Someone above asked what edition I have of the Live Magic LP. Mine is the Capitol Records pressing. Please don't tell me there's a difference between the UK and US editions.
To re-iterate, my research so far demonstrates there is no difference between the audio of the LP and CD, with the exception of the edited "Dayooo" audience participation bit. AND that the listed LP track times are wrong (the songs aren't edited on the LP).
I've presented the facts I've discovered and invited further discussion, unless we've covered everything.
Does anyone know what's going on on the cassette version? Was this released on cassette?
Nothing to add to this except to say that I find discussions of different versions much more interesting than 99% of the other crap we get around here.
If you find something to be pointless and not worth discussing, take your own advice and shut the hell up :) Posting messages about the alleged pointlessness is in itself pointless.
If you find something to be pointless and not worth discussing, take your own advice and shut the hell up :) Posting messages about the alleged pointlessness is in itself pointless.
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]rhyeking wrote: [/QUOTENAME]
...
Honestly, I don't care that you think such tiny details aren't worth attention. Yes, enjoy the music, by all means. If you have no interest in the topic, it ought to be common sense that you should move on to posting in a thread where you can contribute.
...
Queen rocks!
Rhyeking [/QUOTE]
Absolute agred with those parts, buddy.
Cheers, and rock on,
Ogre-
...
Honestly, I don't care that you think such tiny details aren't worth attention. Yes, enjoy the music, by all means. If you have no interest in the topic, it ought to be common sense that you should move on to posting in a thread where you can contribute.
...
Queen rocks!
Rhyeking [/QUOTE]
Absolute agred with those parts, buddy.
Cheers, and rock on,
Ogre-
Rhyeking... don't waste your time justifying yourself. You know you're doing the right thing.