Paul Rodgers or Robbie Williams

When Brian announced Paul, i will very very surprised. Because Robbie approaches group more

What you think about?

WATC - Robbie
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6vDO_yFTsuA
WATC - Paul
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n4L4wLk_FYI

Paul Rodgers any day of the week he's such a good singer and doesn't try to be like Freddie at all in Robbie i can see him trying to be like Freddie to much IMHO

I think Robbie havn't taken because there was a fear that its popularity can eclipse Queen, and set-list would be percent on 40 of Robbie's songs. And that up to concerts in England still it would be not known on what people reacted more, to the Rhapsody or Angels

I prefer what we have now.

Cheers,

Ogre-

Elton John.

Why Elton?

None of the above.

I think I should sing with them.

History has already made the decision.

This has been the topic of conversation for several threads and personally, I am sick of seeing it. In agreement with the post above me, history HAS, indeed, already picked Paul Rodgers for us. Brian May and Roger Taylor, as you all know, are the remaining active members of Queen. They selected Paul Rodgers to tour with them as lead singer in 2005 and 2006 - and as we speak, they are recording an album. Robbie Williams, on the other hand, was not selected. Nor will he ever be. Paul Rodgers is currently fronting Queen, as Freddie Mercury is as dead today as he was yesterday and the day before.

I think I speak for most of Queenzone when I say that I am sick of seeing these idiotic, hypothetical threads created mainly to stir up the "fans" and to get another online "Queen 1991 RIP" tirade. Just as a side note, this thread should have been put in PERSONAL, as Robbie Williams has nothing to do with the topic you selected, which is Queen + Paul Rodgers Tour.

Paul Rodger of coz

Paul Rodgers.

Paul Rodgers, because it's not up to me... so PR it is...

if i compare these two videos then 100% Robbie Williams :) but don't care anyway because they choose Paul, so let it be.

i prefer paul rodgers of course
IMHO, he`s better vocalist than robbie williams
i like robbie, but not to be on stage with queen
on the beginning, i said "damm, why didnt they pick up robbie? he`s such a good singer"
obviously, at that moment, i didnt know paul rodgers...

now i can say that, despite he`s very different than freddie, paul rodgers is an excelent singer and an terrific showman...
i like it
and i dont regret Bri and Rog toured with this guy