I have another copy which is probably lossless but the middle frequencies have been deleted so it is worse than this one.
Thread
Posts in chronological order
[QUOTE]AUDIOCHECKER v1.2 - by Dester - opdester@freemail.hu
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
01 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\01. Procession, Now I'm Here.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 95%
02 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\02.Ogre Battle.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 95%
03 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\03. Father To Son .flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 95%
04 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\04. White Queen.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 98%
05 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\05. Flick Of The Wrist.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 79%
06 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\06.In the Lap Of The Gods.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 98%
07 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\07. Killer Queen.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 98%
08 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\08. The March Of The Black Queen.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: Could not qualify the source of this track.
09 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\09. Bring Back That Leroy Brown.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 95%
10 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\10. Son And Daughter.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: Could not qualify the source of this track.
11 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\11. Keep Yourself Alive.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: Could not qualify the source of this track.
12 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\12. Seven Seas Of Rhye.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 95%
13 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\13. Liar.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: Could not qualify the source of this track.
14 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\14. Stone Cold Crazy.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 95%
15 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\15. In The Lap Of The Gods...Revisited.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 95%
16 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\16. Big Spender, Modern Times.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 91%[/QUOTE]
Like a certain band said: sad but true
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
01 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\01. Procession, Now I'm Here.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 95%
02 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\02.Ogre Battle.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 95%
03 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\03. Father To Son .flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 95%
04 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\04. White Queen.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 98%
05 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\05. Flick Of The Wrist.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 79%
06 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\06.In the Lap Of The Gods.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 98%
07 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\07. Killer Queen.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 98%
08 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\08. The March Of The Black Queen.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: Could not qualify the source of this track.
09 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\09. Bring Back That Leroy Brown.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 95%
10 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\10. Son And Daughter.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: Could not qualify the source of this track.
11 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\11. Keep Yourself Alive.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: Could not qualify the source of this track.
12 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\12. Seven Seas Of Rhye.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 95%
13 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\13. Liar.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: Could not qualify the source of this track.
14 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\14. Stone Cold Crazy.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 95%
15 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\15. In The Lap Of The Gods...Revisited.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 95%
16 -===- D:\downloads\Queen - Manchester 1974\16. Big Spender, Modern Times.flac
Extracted successfully
Conclusion: This track looks like MPEG with probability 91%[/QUOTE]
Like a certain band said: sad but true
Definitely lossy.
There are digital clicks all over it, too. A clean version would be nice to hear, but this mp3 version is all that seems to have circulated.
There are digital clicks all over it, too. A clean version would be nice to hear, but this mp3 version is all that seems to have circulated.
Thanks for having check!
Thanks also for the will to share!
Regards,
Olivier,
France.
Thanks also for the will to share!
Regards,
Olivier,
France.
I'm taking it off from our FLac concert list, then.
Anyway, as Olivier said, thanks for the will to share, Roy!
I hope a good lossless version shows up. Is it likely? :/
Anyway, as Olivier said, thanks for the will to share, Roy!
I hope a good lossless version shows up. Is it likely? :/
OK, I've just checked my version and audiochecker says it's lossy, but the readme file says this
[QUOTE]My copy appears to have noise compression done to it, so it looks lossy but it in fact lossless, based on more thourogh analysis, I have come to that conclusion.[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE]My copy appears to have noise compression done to it, so it looks lossy but it in fact lossless, based on more thourogh analysis, I have come to that conclusion.[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]pittrek wrote: [/QUOTENAME]OK, I've just checked my version and audiochecker says it's lossy, but the readme file says this
[QUOTE]My copy appears to have noise compression done to it, so it looks lossy but it in fact lossless, based on more thourogh analysis, I have come to that conclusion.[/QUOTE][/QUOTE]
Updating the list again?
Hahaha.
Kidding. I'll wait a bit to see whether we come to a collective conclusion, so to speak.
Thanks a lot, Pittrek!
[QUOTE]My copy appears to have noise compression done to it, so it looks lossy but it in fact lossless, based on more thourogh analysis, I have come to that conclusion.[/QUOTE][/QUOTE]
Updating the list again?
Hahaha.
Kidding. I'll wait a bit to see whether we come to a collective conclusion, so to speak.
Thanks a lot, Pittrek!
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]pittrek wrote: [/QUOTENAME]OK, I've just checked my version and audiochecker says it's lossy, but the readme file says this
[QUOTE]My copy appears to have noise compression done to it, so it looks lossy but it in fact lossless, based on more thourogh analysis, I have come to that conclusion.[/QUOTE][/QUOTE]
There's a huge cut at 16 khz. There should be no discussion. Lossy, 100% sure.
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Yara wrote: [/QUOTENAME]I hope a good lossless version shows up. Is it likely? :/[/QUOTE]
The hoarders will always do what they're best at, but maybe some lucky person with the spirit of sharing will get a copy some day.
[QUOTE]My copy appears to have noise compression done to it, so it looks lossy but it in fact lossless, based on more thourogh analysis, I have come to that conclusion.[/QUOTE][/QUOTE]
There's a huge cut at 16 khz. There should be no discussion. Lossy, 100% sure.
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Yara wrote: [/QUOTENAME]I hope a good lossless version shows up. Is it likely? :/[/QUOTE]
The hoarders will always do what they're best at, but maybe some lucky person with the spirit of sharing will get a copy some day.
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Sir GH
wrote: [/QUOTENAME][QUOTE][QUOTENAME]pittrek wrote: [/QUOTENAME]OK, I've just checked my version and audiochecker says it's lossy, but the readme file says this [QUOTE]My copy appears to have noise compression done to it, so it looks lossy but it in fact lossless, based on more thourogh analysis, I have come to that conclusion.[/QUOTE][/QUOTE] There's a huge cut at 16 khz. There should be no discussion. Lossy, 100% sure. [QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Yara wrote: [/QUOTENAME]I hope a good lossless version shows up. Is it likely? :/[/QUOTE] The hoarders will always do what they're best at, but maybe some lucky person with the spirit of sharing will get a copy some day. [/QUOTE] SIRGH! Nice to see ya. :-))) I see this word often, hoard, hoarders, I looked up in my dictionary, and there it says it's the same as collecting, but usually people use it in a...what's the name...like...negative way...detrimental (!? is it?) way! SO, just so I can understand a bit of it all, what's a hoarder? People talk about it over the internet, but sometimes I think are traders, sometimes collectors, is it all the same, no!? * yara's brain on fire *
wrote: [/QUOTENAME][QUOTE][QUOTENAME]pittrek wrote: [/QUOTENAME]OK, I've just checked my version and audiochecker says it's lossy, but the readme file says this [QUOTE]My copy appears to have noise compression done to it, so it looks lossy but it in fact lossless, based on more thourogh analysis, I have come to that conclusion.[/QUOTE][/QUOTE] There's a huge cut at 16 khz. There should be no discussion. Lossy, 100% sure. [QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Yara wrote: [/QUOTENAME]I hope a good lossless version shows up. Is it likely? :/[/QUOTE] The hoarders will always do what they're best at, but maybe some lucky person with the spirit of sharing will get a copy some day. [/QUOTE] SIRGH! Nice to see ya. :-))) I see this word often, hoard, hoarders, I looked up in my dictionary, and there it says it's the same as collecting, but usually people use it in a...what's the name...like...negative way...detrimental (!? is it?) way! SO, just so I can understand a bit of it all, what's a hoarder? People talk about it over the internet, but sometimes I think are traders, sometimes collectors, is it all the same, no!? * yara's brain on fire *
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Sir GH
wrote: [/QUOTENAME][QUOTE][QUOTENAME]pittrek wrote: [/QUOTENAME]OK, I've just checked my version and audiochecker says it's lossy, but the readme file says this [QUOTE]My copy appears to have noise compression done to it, so it looks lossy but it in fact lossless, based on more thourogh analysis, I have come to that conclusion.[/QUOTE][/QUOTE] There's a huge cut at 16 khz. There should be no discussion. Lossy, 100% sure. [QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Yara wrote: [/QUOTENAME]I hope a good lossless version shows up. Is it likely? :/[/QUOTE] The hoarders will always do what they're best at, but maybe some lucky person with the spirit of sharing will get a copy some day. [/QUOTE] I've checked my version - in some parts sounds lossless but in most places it sounds like 128 kbps mp3. The spectrum is mostly cut after 16kHz, but it suddenly jumps over, the same like the "lossless" Hot Space demos. Maybe sourced from a VBR mp3 ?
wrote: [/QUOTENAME][QUOTE][QUOTENAME]pittrek wrote: [/QUOTENAME]OK, I've just checked my version and audiochecker says it's lossy, but the readme file says this [QUOTE]My copy appears to have noise compression done to it, so it looks lossy but it in fact lossless, based on more thourogh analysis, I have come to that conclusion.[/QUOTE][/QUOTE] There's a huge cut at 16 khz. There should be no discussion. Lossy, 100% sure. [QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Yara wrote: [/QUOTENAME]I hope a good lossless version shows up. Is it likely? :/[/QUOTE] The hoarders will always do what they're best at, but maybe some lucky person with the spirit of sharing will get a copy some day. [/QUOTE] I've checked my version - in some parts sounds lossless but in most places it sounds like 128 kbps mp3. The spectrum is mostly cut after 16kHz, but it suddenly jumps over, the same like the "lossless" Hot Space demos. Maybe sourced from a VBR mp3 ?
It's hard to say.
Either way, this one has the digital clicks everywhere so it could be better. I have a clean cassette of this one (the quality itself is still bad), but strangely enough, side B doesn't contain the rest of the Queen concert. Instead it's a recording of people having sex. I'm not kidding! I emailed the person about it, but he didn't reply (maybe it was him on the tape?)!
Either way, this one has the digital clicks everywhere so it could be better. I have a clean cassette of this one (the quality itself is still bad), but strangely enough, side B doesn't contain the rest of the Queen concert. Instead it's a recording of people having sex. I'm not kidding! I emailed the person about it, but he didn't reply (maybe it was him on the tape?)!
Maybe the (un)famous Roger's sex tape in true flac, what a gem!!!
Bob, you should upload it as you have it. Sure there will be more "thank you"s!
Hi QZoners,
the correct dat for this concert is the 20th, isn't it ?
the correct dat for this concert is the 20th, isn't it ?
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]The Keeper wrote: [/QUOTENAME]Hi QZoners,
the correct dat for this concert is the 20th, isn't it ?
[/QUOTE]
No, it's 30th october 74
http://www.queenconcerts.com/detail/live/115/30.10.1974%20-%20Concert:%20Queen%20in%20Palace%20Theatre,%20Manchester,%20UK/
the correct dat for this concert is the 20th, isn't it ?
[/QUOTE]
No, it's 30th october 74
http://www.queenconcerts.com/detail/live/115/30.10.1974%20-%20Concert:%20Queen%20in%20Palace%20Theatre,%20Manchester,%20UK/