Petition against Q+AL?

If you take a look at AL´s fans discussionboards, you´ll se a great difference from here. His fans seem to think that HE was perfect, flawless as they say... :D

Tarabostes 7/4/2012
...and you say you're a Queen fan? Are you sure? Do you offer yourself "to handle" this so-called petition, (to request what, "I don't like AL , please, pretty please Queen , an obscure band at the beginning of your career, don't play with him anymore?) using your real name? Or signed "a group of fans"? Doesn't it sound a little childish?
PS When a petition has to be explained, the petitioner must have problems of logic.

It's beyond some people's fuckin' ability to be realists. He screwed up a lot. Big deal. Petitions about musical acts are still retarded; the only kind I have any remote respect for would be a petition to get someone to visit a certain country or venue.

Otherwise you can cunt off. Your petition is stupid.

[QUOTE] [b]Vela wrote:[/b]
What did you like and not like, Pingfah? I'm only asking because I've watched it over several times and the only things I could find not to like were the technical glitches but that's in the hands of the technicians and the lap of the gods and nothing to do with the guys themselves.[/QUOTE]

The excessive vibrato AL uses was very distracting, I don't like his voice much either, it's too high pitched and squealy.

That said, he got much better as the concert went on. He did make mistakes, but I am prepared to put those down to nerves and give him another chance. Certainly some Queen songs suited him better than others, so I think they should rethink the set.

I thought he was very good on Who Wants to Live Forever.

He badly needs a new haircut though!

Save petitions for things that really matter, like overturning election results that were probably attained by fraud.

[QUOTE] [b]LordOfAllDarkness wrote:[/b]
Stop complaining, Adam Lambert could finally resurrect your dead band, you're supposed to thank him.[/QUOTE]

LOL...

how stupid can you get by making a petition. people who complain about queen + adam lambert cannot call themselves queen fans

I'm willing to defend Bri and Rog touring with Adam for reasons already stated here several times over, namely that it keeps the music alive and keeps two of my favorite musicians playing music, I just won't listen to much of it because I don't like the way Adam's voice sounds with the Queen music. Still, I hope they keep this up. I hope everyone realizes now that the petition is just stupid.

[QUOTE] [b]Vela wrote:[/b]
What a surprise to see ptr here and making yet another comment that does nothing but show ignorance and bias. Amateur footage from the Extravagabondanza sounds better? Sweetheart...... professionally recorded, remixed and remastered footage of that embarrassing pile would still sound like walruses backed by kids on tin drums and washboards.
[/QUOTE]
That's funny, because I have an audience recording of QE, and it sounds absolutely fantastic. Have you even seen the show? I think some of your ignorance and bias is showing.

[QUOTE] [b]Vela wrote:[/b]
What an absurdly over the top reaction from a small (yes, small compared to the positivity) bunch whose heads are clearly as hard as Stonehenge. The guys have found themselves an excellent singer (and it's not like either he or they rushed the decision) who does the songs justice, performs his arse off and has chemistry with the guys. What's not to like?/QUOTE]
You know what, call me stone cold crazy (a song which Adam could not hope to do justice to) but maybe some of the Adam bashers have, dare I say it, and opinion of their own? You can easily throw all the Adam bashers into one group and call them stupid, and also blindly bash the QE, and yet say that people who disagree with you are biased and ignorant? Maybe I'm wrong, but that's what seems to be happening here.

[QUOTE] [b]jazzy mercurois wrote:[/b]
you're all assholes[/QUOTE]
Wow, you're a real nice guy.

wouldn't sign a petition because i really enjoy rbi and rog doing some music again.

AL's "excessive vibrato" is no doubt from his years of technical training. He did grow up a "theater kid.". His is voice may not suit your tastes but I don't think anyone can deny his talent,
Check out this video on YouTube:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DJYyqzUr6jU&feature=youtube_gdata_player


Sent from my iPad

[QUOTE] [b]inu-liger wrote:[/b]
[QUOTE] [b]david (galashiels) wrote:[/b]
anyone looked at adam lamberts fan sites,to see if theres a petition to get rid of bri and rog lol.
[/QUOTE]
DING[/QUOTE]
tl,dr

I don't like it, but I don't care. It's their band, it's their job. As long as they aren't complaining about my job and tell me to do something else, I won't complain about theirs.

[QUOTE] [b]croatiafan wrote:[/b]
After reading all the neagative comments , I would have to say that there are A LOT of angry fans out there, but I don't think it would help much to sing the petition! [/QUOTE]
i agree. probably about as little effect as SIGNING the petition, but possibly a bit more fun ;-)

My opinion about Q+AL is very negative, but I do NOT want to make that open letter in that way... I want to make that open letter as very positive thing like "dont you really think that this would be a better thing for these reasons.... we would love to see that again".

My basic idea is about the discussion and it is NOT (!!!) biased against Lambert, he is the last one who is important for future of Queen. Its about discussion among Brian and Roger... We know that we have no right to enforce anything... Its just about let them notice "we are here and we think that this would be a far better"... Lambert is just singer who accidentaly got this chance...
I liked thatfan video about QAL project with C-lebrity song... I hope that you saw it before it was deleted from youtube... Its exactly MY point of view.

There is one thing which I miss - consistency! I have absolutely NOTHING against them playing the stuff live - music is made to be played live! The problem is about the singer. They never did any real audition for singer to their band. Paul Rodgers was fantastic coincidence - just yesterday I played that very first video of them playing together (Hall Of Fame 2004) - that chemistry is there from the first second when you hear Paul´s voice with Roger´s drumming and Brian´s guitar... These are situation that are absolutely unique. QAL simply do not work that naturally and there are many reasons for that... It was put together by "music business forces", not because of the musical chemistry - simply because this important factor is not there. Thats how I feel it and I know that Im not alone.... I think that the best possible thing (that I KNOW we can get - he have been very positive for new cooperation with them in recent interviews) are some shows with Paul again... I know the guy who did not like the cooperation with Paul, but now? As he heard that Kiev disaster he admited Paul was great compared to this.....

These petition people are making fools of themselves.