John S Stuart
Mr: Queen fan: Even Mozart wrote his musical joke!
Thread
Posts in chronological order
Daro
it's pointless, he's comparing music with food, whatever.
waunakonor
[QUOTE] [b]Haystacks Calhoun II wrote:[/b]
Lighten up , Francis....
What a pathetic life you must lead to get this worked up over a funny song. [/QUOTE]
^Excellent comment, Mr. President.
I think Mr. Queen Fan is making a mistake that's fairy common on these boards, thinking that members of Queen are some kind of gods who should only try to write masterpieces. However, the point of music isn't to be totally perfect and utterly artistic all the time - these days, anyway, music's main objective is to entertain. It's not going to entertain everyone, however. Some people think that music should primarily be written with the audience in mind; some think that the composer of the music is the main concern, and that the audience's opinion matters very little. This is a pretty common debate that veers off the point a little bit. What I'm saying is that Brian did this because he thought it would be fun to do something a little silly, and Weebl evidently thought it was a nice idea too so they went along with it.
I'm not sure, but maybe the reason some people don't like this is that they don't get mrweebl's humor? If that's so, that's fine, but I think the criticism on Brian doesn't make much sense since he's probably not trying to please you specifically anyway.
Like I said before, I really enjoy both the song and the video. My brother was laughing his ass off when he first saw it.
Lighten up , Francis....
What a pathetic life you must lead to get this worked up over a funny song. [/QUOTE]
^Excellent comment, Mr. President.
I think Mr. Queen Fan is making a mistake that's fairy common on these boards, thinking that members of Queen are some kind of gods who should only try to write masterpieces. However, the point of music isn't to be totally perfect and utterly artistic all the time - these days, anyway, music's main objective is to entertain. It's not going to entertain everyone, however. Some people think that music should primarily be written with the audience in mind; some think that the composer of the music is the main concern, and that the audience's opinion matters very little. This is a pretty common debate that veers off the point a little bit. What I'm saying is that Brian did this because he thought it would be fun to do something a little silly, and Weebl evidently thought it was a nice idea too so they went along with it.
I'm not sure, but maybe the reason some people don't like this is that they don't get mrweebl's humor? If that's so, that's fine, but I think the criticism on Brian doesn't make much sense since he's probably not trying to please you specifically anyway.
Like I said before, I really enjoy both the song and the video. My brother was laughing his ass off when he first saw it.
John S Stuart
^ ^
What he said...
What he said...
Daro
yeah!, well said man, i agree 100%.
Mr.QueenFan
[QUOTE] [b]Haystacks Calhoun II wrote:[/b]
Lighten up , Francis....
What a pathetic life you must lead to get this worked up over a funny song. [/QUOTE]
Keyboard warrior, aren´t you?
Try to show some respect! I don´t know you and i believe that i´ve never disrespected you in any way on this forum. I give my honest hopinion, if you don´t like it, then that´s your problem.
Lighten up , Francis....
What a pathetic life you must lead to get this worked up over a funny song. [/QUOTE]
Keyboard warrior, aren´t you?
Try to show some respect! I don´t know you and i believe that i´ve never disrespected you in any way on this forum. I give my honest hopinion, if you don´t like it, then that´s your problem.
Mr.QueenFan
[QUOTE] [b]Daro wrote:[/b]
it's pointless, he's comparing music with food, whatever. [/QUOTE]
I like your style, whatever.
it's pointless, he's comparing music with food, whatever. [/QUOTE]
I like your style, whatever.
Mr.QueenFan
[QUOTE] [b]waunakonor wrote:[/b]
However, the point of music isn't to be totally perfect and utterly artistic all the time.
[/QUOTE]
And this is where i disagree with you, and that´s why i won´t discuss music with you or someone who thinks like this. To me this is just excuses that we as fans find to acomodate the musical faillures of our favourite artists.
But i totally respect your opinion, and i mean it. We just have different views on it.
However, the point of music isn't to be totally perfect and utterly artistic all the time.
[/QUOTE]
And this is where i disagree with you, and that´s why i won´t discuss music with you or someone who thinks like this. To me this is just excuses that we as fans find to acomodate the musical faillures of our favourite artists.
But i totally respect your opinion, and i mean it. We just have different views on it.
John S Stuart
Hey Mr: Queen fan; I think you have a point though...
It's not up there with Bo Rhap, but I don't think it was ever meant to be.
But; I don't think you should be slagged-off for sharing what is after all - YOUR honest opinion.
It's not up there with Bo Rhap, but I don't think it was ever meant to be.
But; I don't think you should be slagged-off for sharing what is after all - YOUR honest opinion.
Mr.QueenFan
[QUOTE] [b]John S Stuart wrote:[/b]
Hey Mr: Queen fan; I think you have a point though...
It's not up there with Bo Rhap, but I don't think it was ever meant to be.
But; I don't think you should be slagged-off for sharing what is after all - YOUR honest opinion.
[/QUOTE]
Thanks for your words.
My point was never to compare Brian to Mozart or Tchaikovsky, that would be ridiculous of me. This is in fact the first time that i can remember that i talked so badly about Brian or any other Queen member project. And in Queenzone, other than the not-so-pleasant words to Greg Brooks i once wrote to him, i like to keep it positive, because i still believe that this site can be great again, provided there is some moderation.
My bringing the names of Mozart and Tchaikovsky was just to state how one man can create 170 cd´s worth of music by the time he´s 35 and the other over 80 hours of music by the time he´s 52. I will let people take their own conclusions.
This topic wasn´t about Brians campaign, and that´s why i allowed myself to talk freely about the music, the video and the effects that can have on public perspective about him as a respected musician. I´m not from UK, so the Badgers is a non issue to me, but i totally support him and i respect him for doing it so.
On the other hand, i could never allow myself to write my reviews on the topic you created, because that was about helping his campaign, and for that matter i will stay positive and aplaud you for taking the initiative to remember Qzoners (to ones interested) how they can help that cause.
And unless something juicy comes up on this thread, i believe this is the end of this discussion to me. I´m not here to fight, and if people don´t like my opinion that´s too bad, because i will continue to be as honest as i can.
Hey Mr: Queen fan; I think you have a point though...
It's not up there with Bo Rhap, but I don't think it was ever meant to be.
But; I don't think you should be slagged-off for sharing what is after all - YOUR honest opinion.
[/QUOTE]
Thanks for your words.
My point was never to compare Brian to Mozart or Tchaikovsky, that would be ridiculous of me. This is in fact the first time that i can remember that i talked so badly about Brian or any other Queen member project. And in Queenzone, other than the not-so-pleasant words to Greg Brooks i once wrote to him, i like to keep it positive, because i still believe that this site can be great again, provided there is some moderation.
My bringing the names of Mozart and Tchaikovsky was just to state how one man can create 170 cd´s worth of music by the time he´s 35 and the other over 80 hours of music by the time he´s 52. I will let people take their own conclusions.
This topic wasn´t about Brians campaign, and that´s why i allowed myself to talk freely about the music, the video and the effects that can have on public perspective about him as a respected musician. I´m not from UK, so the Badgers is a non issue to me, but i totally support him and i respect him for doing it so.
On the other hand, i could never allow myself to write my reviews on the topic you created, because that was about helping his campaign, and for that matter i will stay positive and aplaud you for taking the initiative to remember Qzoners (to ones interested) how they can help that cause.
And unless something juicy comes up on this thread, i believe this is the end of this discussion to me. I´m not here to fight, and if people don´t like my opinion that´s too bad, because i will continue to be as honest as i can.
Daro
[QUOTE] [b]Mr.QueenFan wrote:[/b]
[QUOTE] [b]Daro wrote:[/b]
it's pointless, he's comparing music with food, whatever. [/QUOTE]
I like your style, whatever.
[/QUOTE]
sorry, not trying to be rude, just, agree to disagree? for me music can't be manufactured or made by a recipe, it's art, and as such it's personal and subjective. And by the way the topic of this discussion is a musical joke/internet little support video for tiny cute animals.
[QUOTE] [b]Daro wrote:[/b]
it's pointless, he's comparing music with food, whatever. [/QUOTE]
I like your style, whatever.
[/QUOTE]
sorry, not trying to be rude, just, agree to disagree? for me music can't be manufactured or made by a recipe, it's art, and as such it's personal and subjective. And by the way the topic of this discussion is a musical joke/internet little support video for tiny cute animals.
Mr.QueenFan
[QUOTE] [b]Daro wrote:[/b]
[QUOTE] [b]Mr.QueenFan wrote:[/b]
[QUOTE] [b]Daro wrote:[/b]
it's pointless, he's comparing music with food, whatever. [/QUOTE]
I like your style, whatever.
[/QUOTE]
sorry, not trying to be rude, just, agree to disagree? for me music can't be manufactured or made by a recipe, it's art, and as such it's personal and subjective. And by the way the topic of this discussion is a musical joke/internet little support video for tiny cute animals.[/QUOTE]
Don´t worry, it´s all cool.
And i totally agree with you when you say "for me music can't be manufactured or made by a recipe, it's art, and as such it's personal and subjective". Great post!
[QUOTE] [b]Mr.QueenFan wrote:[/b]
[QUOTE] [b]Daro wrote:[/b]
it's pointless, he's comparing music with food, whatever. [/QUOTE]
I like your style, whatever.
[/QUOTE]
sorry, not trying to be rude, just, agree to disagree? for me music can't be manufactured or made by a recipe, it's art, and as such it's personal and subjective. And by the way the topic of this discussion is a musical joke/internet little support video for tiny cute animals.[/QUOTE]
Don´t worry, it´s all cool.
And i totally agree with you when you say "for me music can't be manufactured or made by a recipe, it's art, and as such it's personal and subjective". Great post!
Daro
[QUOTE] [b]Mr.QueenFan wrote:[/b]
[QUOTE] [b]Daro wrote:[/b]
[QUOTE] [b]Mr.QueenFan wrote:[/b]
[QUOTE] [b]Daro wrote:[/b]
it's pointless, he's comparing music with food, whatever. [/QUOTE]
I like your style, whatever.
[/QUOTE]
sorry, not trying to be rude, just, agree to disagree? for me music can't be manufactured or made by a recipe, it's art, and as such it's personal and subjective. And by the way the topic of this discussion is a musical joke/internet little support video for tiny cute animals.[/QUOTE]
Don´t worry, it´s all cool.
And i totally agree with you when you say "for me music can't be manufactured or made by a recipe, it's art, and as such it's personal and subjective". Great post!
[/QUOTE]
thanx a bunch, really enjoying this thread by the way.
[QUOTE] [b]Daro wrote:[/b]
[QUOTE] [b]Mr.QueenFan wrote:[/b]
[QUOTE] [b]Daro wrote:[/b]
it's pointless, he's comparing music with food, whatever. [/QUOTE]
I like your style, whatever.
[/QUOTE]
sorry, not trying to be rude, just, agree to disagree? for me music can't be manufactured or made by a recipe, it's art, and as such it's personal and subjective. And by the way the topic of this discussion is a musical joke/internet little support video for tiny cute animals.[/QUOTE]
Don´t worry, it´s all cool.
And i totally agree with you when you say "for me music can't be manufactured or made by a recipe, it's art, and as such it's personal and subjective". Great post!
[/QUOTE]
thanx a bunch, really enjoying this thread by the way.