Regarding Rock Montreal colours (!)

Can somebody point to that bit in Let Me Entertain You in a Youtube vid? I can't see the delay issue everyone's talking about.

1 minute and 35 seconds mark

You can see it better at 1:55. Look at Roger's drumming, where you hear the snare when he pulls his hand AWAY from the snare drum.

I have no delay issues, he hits the snare at pretty much exactly the same time as the audio. Even at 0.25x speed. Wonder if it has something to do with Flash Player, sound card, CPU, etc?

Hmm, well I didn't really think of looking into the audio aspect of this, because the DTS was muxed in directly from the BR trusting it would have been good enough. I didn't have audio in the timeline because it would have likely slowed down my PC even more so didn't really spot any sync issues.

Try to "air-drum" on various parts of the concert where it's possible to see Roger hiting things. It will be even more noticable.

[QUOTE] [b]Oscar J wrote:[/b]

I have no delay issues, he hits the snare at pretty much exactly the same time as the audio. Even at 0.25x speed. Wonder if it has something to do with Flash Player, sound card, CPU, etc?

[/QUOTE]

See? Because of people like you they don't bother to sync it properly :-)

Honestly, the delay IS there and it's not constant, for example in this particular video Freddie is synchronised often correctly, but Roger is often not. But I do understand that not everybody notices stuff like that. Most of people won't.

Well, the video would need to be cut up and adjusted to fit the audio but they're using the original cut and they have no rushes right? Would anyone really want to chop up and adjust the audio? I think there is no fix apart from just trying not to notice it. If I missed something or I'm wrong, correct me please.

I agree, ignoring it is probably the best solution. I am pretty sure 90% of people won't notice it.

Since I was going to (de)mux the mkv to add the subtitle track with the lyrics like the 2002 dvd, I added the -100ms delay that nitroboy suggested and it goes really well.

I checked with Love of my life, get down make love, bohemian rhapsody and another one bites the dust and the snare hits are in sync and still can't find any parts where Freddie is unsynchronized.

[QUOTE] [b]Oscar J wrote: [/b] I have no delay issues, he hits the snare at pretty much exactly the same time as the audio. Even at 0.25x speed. Wonder if it has something to do with Flash Player, sound card, CPU, etc? [/QUOTE] Flash player? You asked for a youtube video so you could see what i'm talking about. We're talking Blu-Ray. The problem is there in the original. The begining of Keep Yourself Alive is another good example. Try air-druming in Keep Yourself Alive intro and keep looking at Roger. You'll go out of sync. It's a problem in the original Blu-Ray, not the flash player, CPU, etc.  

It is much more noticeable in this. It is also noticeable 1:35 into the LMEY video, but at 1:55 the audio isn't out of sync anymore as far as I can tell. Like pittrek said, it probably comes and goes.

Was considering hardware/software reasons since we were discussing delays at specific timestamps in a youtube video, and Nitroboy was hearing a delay in a spot I definitely didn't. But I'm sure the delay issues are there in the original Blu-Ray as well.

But yeah, I'm definitely among the 90 % who don't care. The music is what it's all about for me. :)

[QUOTE] [b]pittrek wrote:[/b]

I agree, ignoring it is probably the best solution. I am pretty sure 90% of people won't notice it.[/QUOTE]

I haven´t watch Montreal in ages, but I noticed a BIG problem of sync (with Roger too) during ITLOG in Rainbow release :O

They seem to have some "problems" mixing two nights... so, what could we expect with Earls Court if they choose to do these 2xNight compilations? (well, in the case they decided to release it)

The Blu-Ray is a audiovisual medium so when i buy a movie, tv series or a concert, the one thing that i would expect is the audio being in sync with the video. If i didn't care about it, i would just listen to the CD of the concert, or rip the audio from the Blu-Ray. But don't expect anyone buying a Blu-Ray to watch and hear a concert and NOT be bothered when video and audio are out of sync all the time.

[QUOTE] [b]MERQRY wrote:[/b]

[QUOTE] [b]pittrek wrote:[/b]

I agree, ignoring it is probably the best solution. I am pretty sure 90% of people won't notice it.[/QUOTE]

I haven´t watch Montreal in ages, but I noticed a BIG problem of sync (with Roger too) during ITLOG in Rainbow release :O

They seem to have some "problems" mixing two nights... so, what could we expect with Earls Court if they choose to do these 2xNight compilations? (well, in the case they decided to release it)
[/QUOTE]

Hey, can you check your PMs? I sent you one a few weeks/months ago :-)