The real reason Queen is touring with Lambert.

But it's pointless to say that it was already recorded if the recording has Freddie on vocals, since my claim was that it was Freddie vocals, feel and expression that is the magic. The only way it would make sense to say that it was already recorded iwould be if there is an earlier version done in pretty much this form and done completely without Freddie and with Roger on vocals.

Now go away and quit wasting my time.

Gerry was attacked for not knowing Mott the hoople?

That's very similar to me being attacked for allegedly not knowing that there is highlander version of AKOM, as if forgot to listen to the bonus disc that came with my 2011 remaster of the album and which I paid extra for.

Goes to show how fucking ridiculous some people are. No attempt to learn and discover the truth. Confuse, obfuscate and win arguments is the name of the game it seems.

Let’s just say , from what clips we see of Queen in the studio Freddie does appear to be dominant but also a team player.

If there was something of value they all contributed.

And as for magnifying the contribution of Brian to the guitar solo in Bo Rhap, bloody hell, that’s also straight out the film .

[QUOTE] [b]brENsKi wrote:[/b]

no matter who you choose to "remember it" Roger did the heavy lifting in the 80s,
[/QUOTE]

^

This

I think Roger had a better feel for what would make a hit song than Brian. I also sense that Freddie was getting very jaded with queen and with pop music in general in the early to mid eighties. He wanted to do opera, classical, and stuff like that.

You people are Queen fans?

This is stupid. Grow the hell up.

Borap13, yes we are fans, not blind worshipers. There is a difference, which you, being a blind worshiper, obviously have great difficulty distinguishing.

[QUOTE] [b]Freddie Jupiter wrote:[/b]I think Roger had a better feel for what would make a hit song than Brian. I also sense that Freddie was getting very jaded with queen and with pop music in general in the early to mid eighties. He wanted to do opera, classical, and stuff like that. [/QUOTE] Roger wrote almost half of big hits from 84-91. We all know what Freddie wanted to do: drink, drugs, sex, parties...which is why his writing from 82-86 reflected this.
His music "grew up" classical etc - once he found out he was on "borrowed time", and decided he wanted to leave the world something with quality from that period.


[QUOTE] [b]AlbaNo1 wrote:[/b]And as for magnifying the contribution of Brian to the guitar solo in Bo Rhap, bloody hell, that’s also straight out the film .[/QUOTE]you do realise my Bo Rhap comment was sarcasm directed at FJ's writing credit claim?


[QUOTE] [b]Freddie Jupiter wrote:[/b]This is a link to a finished version of the song with vocals by Freddie. I said the vocals and the feel of the song is the magic, as the lyrics are pretty mediocre, and you link me to a version of the song with vocals by Freddie WTF? [/QUOTE]so in essence, you're now shifting your ever moving goalposts onto an entirely different strip of grass...in another town.
you could say this about EVERY great song ever written.
let's apply your rule:
>> Elvis now gets a writing credit for every song he sung on? - he never actually wrote anything.
>> Beatles songwriting credits are now divvied up according to who sang lead
>> ALL Led Zep songs were written by Plant
>> ALL Rush songs were written by Geddy Lee
>> ALL ABBA songs were written by Anni-Fridd and Agnetha
what utter nonsense. the writer/concept creator IS the writer - regardless of who tweaked what.
you're just here to argue the toss for the sake of it. get grip of reality, and grow up.

Brenski, if you have a point to make, make it, instead of posting these dog's breakfast posts that seem to be saying five seemingly contradictory things all at once.

Maybe break it up into individual posts, making sure that each post makes one single point as clearly and concisely as possible.

Give it a shot.

[QUOTE] [b]Freddie Jupiter wrote:[/b]

But it's pointless to say that it was already recorded if the recording has Freddie on vocals, since my claim was that it was Freddie vocals, feel and expression that is the magic. The only way it would make sense to say that it was already recorded iwould be if there is an earlier version done in pretty much this form and done completely without Freddie and with Roger on vocals.
[/QUOTE]

That's not what you asked. It's there for all to see.

[QUOTE] [b]Freddie Jupiter wrote:[/b]
Now go away and quit wasting my time.[/QUOTE]

No. It's amazing that someone like you, who is all over the forum telling us what to think, how Brian thinks, how Fred thinks, etc., has so little basic knowledge of Queen.

@Holly, you've completely lost me now. I honestly have no idea what you're talking about.

Also, how the fuck did you come to the conclusion that I lack knowledge about queen.

You strike me as a very intellectually dishonest person, and I have zero patience for intellectual dishonesty.

[QUOTE] [b]Freddie Jupiter wrote:[/b]

@Holly, you've completely lost me now. I honestly have no idea what you're talking about.

Also, how the fuck did you come to the conclusion that I lack knowledge about queen.

You strike me as a very intellectually dishonest person, and I have zero patience for intellectual dishonesty. [/QUOTE]

Since you are a fake account -- someone else's 2nd or 3rd personality on the forum -- your fictional characteristics are of no interest to me.

You couldn't be more wrong. I'm nobody else's fake account. Clearly you don't know shit, so stop pretending that you do.

[QUOTE] [b]Freddie Jupiter wrote:[/b]

You couldn't be more wrong. I'm nobody else's fake account. Clearly you don't know shit, so stop pretending that you do.

[/QUOTE]

That's very rude. You should make your fictional character more polite. And give him/her more Queen knowledge so you don't look so foolish.

You're the one who's rude. First you accuse me of having a 2nd or 3rd account, which is not the case. And secondly you try to obfuscate the argument by talking about accounts.

Either respond to the argument in hand or go away, instead of bringing in some bullshit about accounts. Even if this were my millionth account it would have zero relevance to the discussion in this thread.