Who is the 5th Queen member ?

tomnever 07 July 2004 18:13 · Member since September 2003

There is some legends about the fifth Beatle...

Then WHO is the fifth Queen member ?

Jim Beach ?
Spike Edney ?
Mack ?
David Richards ?
Crystal ?
Morgan Fisher ?
Mike Moran ?
Roy Thomas Baker ?
Tim Staffell ?
Other ?

I vote for Spike !

G

Gunpowder Gelatine 07 July 2004 18:14 · Member since July 2004

All of them! They were just one big happy family!

P

Penetration_Guru 07 July 2004 18:17 · Member since July 2001

er...they were a four piece band.

F

Flashman 07 July 2004 18:18 · Member since August 2002

Yes, I've double checked the cover of Greatest Hits and there were definitely only four of them.

T

tomnever 07 July 2004 18:19 · Member since September 2003

I forgot to say why I vote for Spike.

He's the person who helped to brought Queen back to the top with Live Aid, formed a band with RMT, another one with BHM, and keeps in a way the legend alive with his excellent SAS Band.

He is a very underestimated man in music, IMO.

And if somebody had to replace John, he's the man to do the job. Unfortunaltely, I don't think bass guitar is his most beloved instrument ;-)

What do U think ?

T

tomnever 07 July 2004 18:23 · Member since September 2003

Of course I know there were a 4 piece band.
But this is a theorical exercise, people ;-)

I guess U know the "legends" about the 5th Beatle Stuart Sutcliffe, even this is very different.

F

Flashman 07 July 2004 18:25 · Member since August 2002

I always thought gap-toothed funnyman Jimmy Tarbuck was the fifth Beatle.

I

iGSM 07 July 2004 20:30 · Member since May 2003

Well you'd have to say Spike...and those other two pianists before him. Barry and..Jeff.

A

Arnaldo "Ogre-" Silveira 07 July 2004 22:13 · Member since July 2001

Spike. In the "also ran" category, or course. :)

W

Wilki Amieva 07 July 2004 23:01 · Member since May 2002

John Deacon.

A

akindofmagic 07 July 2004 23:28 · Member since July 2001

What About Mary Austin( this lady got well more prettiest on her mid-age then on her youth)? She was a person around Queen FRom the right beggining till the end!

But i think that the outside member that, in just few years(4 or 5) had a highest input on band was Mike Moran. He wrote a fantastic album with Freddie , put a song of his own in a Queen album(quite rare) and gave his music finger to the guys.

Spike... well , you know... he is family...

T

The Real Wizard 08 July 2004 00:48 · Member since August 2002

Roy Thomas Baker - 73-78
Mack 80-82
David Richards 84-95

Production is always something that is extremely underrated. If George Martin is the fifth Beatle (and rightfully so), then these three are the fifth Queenies in their respective time periods.

B

Brian_Mays_Wig 08 July 2004 06:28 · Member since December 2002

Spike Edney is a very under - estimated man in music. I looked at his bio on a web page a few months back and the amount of stuff he did before he worked with Queen and outside Queen is amazing. But like it was mentioned before, They were all one big happy family!!!
They were a 4 piece band, I just double checked my greatest hits LP's to make sure Flashman wasnt lying ;)

B

Brian_Mays_Wig 08 July 2004 06:47 · Member since December 2002

Wasnt he the pianist in the early 80s??? The one with the fondness for orange??? Strange bloke. Great pianist though!

M

Mr. Scully 08 July 2004 07:03 · Member since July 2001

Undoubtedly Jim Beach.

Spike Edney is called the fifth member of Queen above all because he started calling himself like that. At least that's what some people from the "inner circle" say. I think Queen were a nice boost for Spike's career.

But truth is that IF the fifth member of Queen is a musician, it has to be Spike. Who else?

Posts in chronological order