'Fake' recordings

djaef 03 May 2005 03:06 · Member since July 2004

No-one has suggested how the Fat Bottomed Girls one is fake (and Sergey, you don't have that on your web site list). I've listen to it again and again, and I can hear different guitars as well as vocals in a totally different key.

My other question is about Silver Salmon. I've read that there is only one version, and all others are faked. Is this right, and if so, which is the real one?

F

Fenderek 03 May 2005 08:17 · Member since July 2003

Fat Bottomed Girls may be the stuff from Hollywood's JAZZ. It's a remix though, not a demo.

S

Serry... 03 May 2005 09:42 · Member since October 2004

Yes, there's Brian Malouf remix for HR Jazz reissue - it contains more vocal, and probably different drums.

And on "The Ultimate Collection" is 'First take' version - someone says it'a a little bit different, someone - it's similar to single's version. IMO, it's a fake too.

About SS - I don't know really. Check John S. Stuart's Ultimate Collection for more details, I think all those 'Silver Salmon's are just different cuts of one version.

I've just updated that page with FBG, thanks for the help!

S

Serry... 07 May 2005 10:38 · Member since October 2004

According to John S. Stuart's Ultimate Collection there's only one 'Silver Salmon' version, so I was right probably (I've heard only one version, so I don't know), but still need in confirmation for adding it to my site (I've updated my list of fake recordings, any additions and corrections are still welcome!)

http://serryfunster.narod.ru/fakes.htm

W

Wombat 08 May 2005 13:58 · Member since December 2004

we all know this

S

Serry... 09 May 2005 09:48 · Member since October 2004