Can anyone recommend the best version Hangman that is availible. I have a couple of versions, but I am sure there are more.
What are your thoughts?
Thread
Posts in chronological order
Japan 1975 is probably the best one..
Unless you get your hands on JSS acetate.
Unless you get your hands on JSS acetate.
Thanks for you help. Not much chance of getting the acetate I supose
Are we talking best in terms of sound quality or how well they played the song? I'd love to hear that Japan performance.
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Michael Allred wrote: [/QUOTENAME]Are we talking best in terms of sound quality or how well they played the song? I'd love to hear that Japan performance.[/QUOTE]
You can download it in the announce forum "Shizuoka 1975"
You can download it in the announce forum "Shizuoka 1975"
So far, best quality are on YOUNG NOBLES OF ROCK (2cd) bootleg)
I don't think there are any acetate disc made of that song in any take. Rehearsals tape, or other takes on TAPE might be in the Queen archive, or Brian's private archive. But that's all.
www.queenonstage.com
I don't think there are any acetate disc made of that song in any take. Rehearsals tape, or other takes on TAPE might be in the Queen archive, or Brian's private archive. But that's all.
www.queenonstage.com
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Long John Silver wrote: [/QUOTENAME]So far, best quality are on YOUNG NOBLES OF ROCK (2cd) bootleg)
I don't think there are any acetate disc made of that song in any take. Rehearsals tape, or other takes on TAPE might be in the Queen archive, or Brian's private archive. But that's all.
www.queenonstage.com
[/QUOTE]
Why not?
I think JSS has an acetate with a Hangman studio version. If he says he has, I have no reason to doubt that.
I don't think there are any acetate disc made of that song in any take. Rehearsals tape, or other takes on TAPE might be in the Queen archive, or Brian's private archive. But that's all.
www.queenonstage.com
[/QUOTE]
Why not?
I think JSS has an acetate with a Hangman studio version. If he says he has, I have no reason to doubt that.
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Long John Silver wrote: [/QUOTENAME]So far, best quality are on YOUNG NOBLES OF ROCK (2cd) bootleg)
I don't think there are any acetate disc made of that song in any take. Rehearsals tape, or other takes on TAPE might be in the Queen archive, or Brian's private archive. But that's all.
www.queenonstage.com
[/QUOTE]
If an acetate does indeed exist, then the likelyhood of the multitracks and any stereo mixdowns being wiped or since lost is zilch.
I don't think there are any acetate disc made of that song in any take. Rehearsals tape, or other takes on TAPE might be in the Queen archive, or Brian's private archive. But that's all.
www.queenonstage.com
[/QUOTE]
If an acetate does indeed exist, then the likelyhood of the multitracks and any stereo mixdowns being wiped or since lost is zilch.
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Negative Creep wrote: [/QUOTENAME][QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Long John Silver wrote: [/QUOTENAME]So far, best quality are on YOUNG NOBLES OF ROCK (2cd) bootleg)
I don't think there are any acetate disc made of that song in any take. Rehearsals tape, or other takes on TAPE might be in the Queen archive, or Brian's private archive. But that's all.
www.queenonstage.com
[/QUOTE]
If an acetate does indeed exist, then the likelyhood of the multitracks and any stereo mixdowns being wiped or since lost is zilch.[/QUOTE]
I think anything is possible in 30+ years.
I don't think there are any acetate disc made of that song in any take. Rehearsals tape, or other takes on TAPE might be in the Queen archive, or Brian's private archive. But that's all.
www.queenonstage.com
[/QUOTE]
If an acetate does indeed exist, then the likelyhood of the multitracks and any stereo mixdowns being wiped or since lost is zilch.[/QUOTE]
I think anything is possible in 30+ years.
Well can't we ask JSS to upload just a snippet, eg. about 10 sec or so to prove he has it...And can he or someone also explain why Hangman is pressed as an accetate, because mostly only single releases were pressed on a accetate ? What do you think about that ?
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]shadysenator wrote: [/QUOTENAME]Well can't we ask JSS to upload just a snippet, eg. about 10 sec or so to prove he has it...And can he or someone also explain why Hangman is pressed as an accetate, because mostly only single releases were pressed on a accetate ? What do you think about that ?[/QUOTE]
Well I guess you're new here, so I'll be polite
1.) If JSS tells us he HAS it, then he HAS it. He does not NEED to prove us ANYTHING.
2.) He has the acetate, he didn't transfer it into any digital format
3.) He will NOT share it
Well I guess you're new here, so I'll be polite
1.) If JSS tells us he HAS it, then he HAS it. He does not NEED to prove us ANYTHING.
2.) He has the acetate, he didn't transfer it into any digital format
3.) He will NOT share it
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]shadysenator wrote: [/QUOTENAME]Well can't we ask JSS to upload just a snippet, eg. about 10 sec or so to prove he has it...And can he or someone also explain why Hangman is pressed as an accetate, because mostly only single releases were pressed on a accetate ? What do you think about that ?[/QUOTE]
What's the use of a 10 second snippet? That's like 2 guitar strokes.
Might as well upload 10 seconds of brighton rock saying it's the Blag demo.
What's the use of a 10 second snippet? That's like 2 guitar strokes.
Might as well upload 10 seconds of brighton rock saying it's the Blag demo.
[QUOTE][QUOTENAME]Leaky Luke wrote: [/QUOTENAME][QUOTE][QUOTENAME]shadysenator wrote: [/QUOTENAME]Well can't we ask JSS to upload just a snippet, eg. about 10 sec or so to prove he has it...And can he or someone also explain why Hangman is pressed as an accetate, because mostly only single releases were pressed on a accetate ? What do you think about that ?[/QUOTE]
What's the use of a 10 second snippet? That's like 2 guitar strokes.
Might as well upload 10 seconds of brighton rock saying it's the Blag demo.[/QUOTE]
And apart from that, as soon as snippets are shared on this web-site, people demand the full track. It happened before, and it will happen again.
If John decides not to share this track, it's his choice. He paid a lot of money for it, and once QP starts to show interest, he'll be able to sell it for a lot of money as well. Sharing it for free would be nonsense (IMO).
What's the use of a 10 second snippet? That's like 2 guitar strokes.
Might as well upload 10 seconds of brighton rock saying it's the Blag demo.[/QUOTE]
And apart from that, as soon as snippets are shared on this web-site, people demand the full track. It happened before, and it will happen again.
If John decides not to share this track, it's his choice. He paid a lot of money for it, and once QP starts to show interest, he'll be able to sell it for a lot of money as well. Sharing it for free would be nonsense (IMO).
Okay I get the point, forget that you see JSS as God ....
But then my 2nd question, why is there a acetate of this song isn't it that acetate are only made from songs which are going to be released as a single.... sounds a little strange to me that a non single track will be acetated .... give me your thoughts on this one please... Therefore i doubt that the hangman acetate excists...otherwise JSS give us the logical reason for a Hangman acetate.
And can Greg Brooks our queen archivist add some information about this one ?
But then my 2nd question, why is there a acetate of this song isn't it that acetate are only made from songs which are going to be released as a single.... sounds a little strange to me that a non single track will be acetated .... give me your thoughts on this one please... Therefore i doubt that the hangman acetate excists...otherwise JSS give us the logical reason for a Hangman acetate.
And can Greg Brooks our queen archivist add some information about this one ?
Sheep