"a Anita Dobson cover"
How's it a "cover" when her version was recorded a good 4 years after the original Queen version?? That's a pretty unfair statement to make there dude, and I almost NEVER disagree with you elsewhere!
Thread
Posts in chronological order
You are right Inu. But.. :)
It's a cover in commercial terms, which came first? The Anita Dobson version. It will probably sound good and of course it will as a Queen track.
I am looking at this from a marketing point of view, you always put your best out front in the front window, the best of this album is a reworked Fred track which I like but it's not original work neither is the Dobson track yes I acknowledge Queen recorded it first but again it's recycled stuff we have heard in someway already, Anita used Freddie's vocal track as a guide so it's going to be very similar. If this is the cream of the crop I am prepared for disappointment.
I'm not trying to be negative here and I understand I am in the vast minority but I think this album will be a let down. I think old age is making me a bit conservative and I do wonder if they should be reworking tracks just because they have a Freddie vocal track.
It's a cover in commercial terms, which came first? The Anita Dobson version. It will probably sound good and of course it will as a Queen track.
I am looking at this from a marketing point of view, you always put your best out front in the front window, the best of this album is a reworked Fred track which I like but it's not original work neither is the Dobson track yes I acknowledge Queen recorded it first but again it's recycled stuff we have heard in someway already, Anita used Freddie's vocal track as a guide so it's going to be very similar. If this is the cream of the crop I am prepared for disappointment.
I'm not trying to be negative here and I understand I am in the vast minority but I think this album will be a let down. I think old age is making me a bit conservative and I do wonder if they should be reworking tracks just because they have a Freddie vocal track.
Have we heard let me in ( your heart again) before?
Jefffab1995 wrote:
Have we heard let me in ( your heart again) before?
If only from Anita lips, not Freddie.
Ok didn't know anita recorded it
Jefffab1995 wrote:
Ok didn't know anita recorded it
I sure on 100 percent that from Freddie's lips it'll be sound more powerful.
^^^^^ oh god he's replying to himself!
scottmax wrote:
^^^^^ oh god he's replying to himself!
What do you mean?
We all know you're the same person
scottmax wrote:
We all know you're the same person
No, I don't
scottmax wrote:
We all know you're the same person
No he is a russian
Im a cool american!
Jefffab1995 wrote:
scottmax wrote:
We all know you're the same person
No he is a russian
Im a cool american!
You're great jeffab 1995,
I'm great too.
Mh17
Oh no, not again Freddie solo songs on a Queen album. Freddie solo is Freddie solo and not Queen. The did the same on the Made in Heaven album and these songs had nothing to do with Queen.
Quite a few of the tracks from Mr bad guy were tracks Queen rejected !