Yes... RealWizard. Of course it wasn't posted here on QZ, but there were a couple of Adam fans on the OIQFC facebook page who act as if Adam is the best thing that happened to Queen. [/QUOTE]
I not sure that Adam is the best thing that happened to Queen.
thomasquinn 32989 · Member since
[QUOTE] [b]DragonflyTrumpeter83 wrote:[/b]
Yes... RealWizard. Of course it wasn't posted here on QZ, but there were a couple of Adam fans on the OIQFC facebook page who act as if Adam is the best thing that happened to Queen. [/QUOTE]
But does the opinion of a bunch of cult-like AL-stepfords really have any value when talking about Queen? It'd be like taking seriously a 5ive-fan who claims their version of WWRY is the best thing Queen ever did, or, more reasonably, a George Michael-fan appraising Five Live.
tomchristie22 · Member since
Holy wow. Like many, I was just expecting an instrumental mess around like Leroy Brown - this is incredible. Even more hyped for the full release now!
tomchristie22 · Member since
Freddie absolutely NAILS the 'soldier, sailor, tinker, tailor...' part. Aahgh.
j0ck3 · Member since
Having listened to the full song a handful of times now it's still as great as the preview hinted at.
However I do see a paralell here to their future decision of not attempting the Opera section live in Bohemian Rhapsody. The live version here omits so many small vocal details that's there in the studio version while not adding anything apart from a short acapella.
Brian says they didn't play it often and I would guess that is because of how difficult the song is vocally for both Freddie and Roger. The instrumental parts are stellar though and in my opinion a highlight of the March show.
Hank H. · Member since
This sounds almost too good to be the original live recording. We'll never know how much of it is overdubbed or corrected, will we? If they did play it that well, they must have rehearsed it a lot. But after so much effort you'd expect them to keep it in the setlist...
tomchristie22 · Member since
Loving all the arguments early in this threads about how it's too hard or complex to have played live. It's like everyone forgot they played Keep Yourself Alive and Death on Two Legs live, both of which have lots of overlapping lead vocal.
Oscar J · Member since
They had an extraordinary ability to keep complex songs together. I think Taylor and Deacon are responsible for much of that, they just didn't miss a beat.
cmsdrums · Member since
[QUOTE] [b]Oscar J wrote:[/b]
They had an extraordinary ability to keep complex songs together. I think Taylor and Deacon are responsible for much of that, they just didn't miss a beat. [/QUOTE]
Spot on - everyone can probably names countless Freddie and Brian slip ups across a number of bootlegs, but listen to a 100 gigs and you'll probably only need a couple of fingers to count up mistakes by Roger and John.
(... 'runs away and hides after opening himself up for people to produce a long list of Queen rhythm section faux-pas!!')
Oscar J · Member since
There's a real train wreck in the Golders Green version of See What A Fool I've been though. I remember Roger really losing track in some version of In Love With My Car as well, but that had more to do with the singing I think. So yeah, there are really few examples.
Brian on the other hand always messes up things, but I forgive him because he was my biggest inspiration in my guitar playing for a long time.
