A comparison of Live at the Rainbow (2014) and previous versions
72 posts
Thread
Posts in chronological order
tomchristie22 · Member since
Download link (pdf) (last updated November 4th 2014): [url=https://mega.co.nz/#!90RjhAzB!ay4pF_2LjiV4padWS9YGx5Xy8wzOGtlxvSDc8u2Jr8o]https://mega.co.nz/#!90RjhAzB!ay4pF_2LjiV4padWS9YGx5Xy8wzOGtlxvSDc8u2Jr8o[/url]
I've listened through the 2014 releases of both the March and combined November concerts, and examined the songs in comparison to what's available on previous bootlegs and other releases.
This is just something I wanted to do - If it's helpful to anyone, that'll be a great bonus. I reached more useful conclusions on the March concert than the November ones, as it's much easier to determine if something's an overdub, pitch corrected, etc. when there was only one night played, thus only one possible 'accurate' version.
The fact that we know very little of what comes from what night in the November concerts made it very difficult to conclude many specifics, but I think it's worth a read nonetheless.
There are summaries for the differences in each song, for those who don't want to read about discrepancies in the smaller details.
Nitroboy · Member since
Interesting read, thanks for the writing :)
GinjaNinja · Member since
Really enjoyed that, excellent work. I watched the first night at the SiS exhibition but I'm afraid I can't remember any specifics about it. However, there should be a (silent) video I recorded of Flick Of The Wrist from the first night somewhere on this forum, which might be helpful for analysis. Also, it seems that they (at least for the main part of the set) had the "Queen" sign up behind them only on the first night, so that could also help to identify which nights the songs are from.
KumoNin · Member since
It may have been worth noting that some notable, ear-piercing guitar feedback had been removed for 2014 at the beginning of March Ogre Battle...
Ale Solan · Member since
Excellent work Tom! kudos to you! ;)
Oscar J · Member since
Wow, great job!
The line "You said you'd equal any man for having your fun" from S&D (March) has been fixed too, as the word "fun" was extremely pitchy in the original.
DepeX · Member since
Great work! Thanks mate
The Real Wizard · Member since
Oh man, this is gonna be good. Looking forward to it !
LucasDiego · Member since
Excellen text, rainbow is a excellent release, but there are moments on CD and DVD, that i suspected strage effects in freddie´s voice, and this text confirmed.
brians wig · Member since
Wow.
The Real Wizard · Member since
An addition - Roger's drum fill in the first chorus of Ogre Battle 3-31-74 (after "come tonight") was a bit sloppy, so they replaced it with drum parts from some other spot in the show.
winterspelt · Member since
Thanks!
The Real Wizard · Member since
[QUOTE][b]document, re: Now I'm Here @ 0:57 says:[/b]
perhaps it was impossible to separate from the harmonies
[/QUOTE]
Perhaps, but I still call bullshit because they had two nights to work with, and certainly even other Queen shows (or studio outtakes) that they could've used the vocal from. They cleaned up the Liar flub on Hammersmith 75 this way.
Also noteworthy is the edit at 3:22 that has been on every version dating back to the half-hour cinema edit in 1976. A bar of the song is missing, perhaps because the band didn't cleanly make their way into the next section. Again, they had two nights to work with...
tomchristie22 · Member since
Thanks for the positive feedback guys, I'm really glad this is of some use :)
I'll definitely check out all the suggestions and add them in. Please feel free to post anything else that I've missed so I can include it!
[QUOTE] [b]GinjaNinja wrote:[/b]
It seems that they (at least for the main part of the set) had the "Queen" sign up behind them only on the first night, so that could also help to identify which nights the songs are from.[/QUOTE]
Well! If that's the case, then pretty much all the wide shots in the 2014 version must be from the first night. I'll definitely look into this soon.
The Real Wizard · Member since
[QUOTE] [b]GinjaNinja wrote:[/b]
Also, it seems that they (at least for the main part of the set) had the "Queen" sign up behind them only on the first night, so that could also help to identify which nights the songs are from.[/QUOTE]
Interesting - how do you know this for sure?
And of course, this only counts for the video and not the audio necessarily..