Bullwinkle: "...could you please provide some comment... regarding QP attempted stingyness regarding the KYA and MtS Hollywood bonus tracks?"
To be honest with you - I don't know, and I don't know how to answer.
What I do know is that they were "accidently" released, therefore, if it were not for this fortunate mishap (it is my strong opinion) they would still not have seen the light of day.
Whisperer: Sorry just seen your mail (don't know how I missed it). "Do you have the Hangman acetate?" - NO comment!!!
Thread
Posts in chronological order
thank you - now go to bed - Has the sun risen there yet?
A flyer for this concert is briefly viewed in the official “Genesis - Archive” video
A technical note... it's a boxed set of audio recordings... very little video exists of early Genesis, unfortunately!
[/QUOTE]
Do you have the Hangman acetate? No, I'm not going to ask for an mp3, I'm not an idiot. I just want to find out if there is an acetate of that song that we know for sure isn't destroyed.[/QUOTE]
I don't think asking for an extremely rare mp3 would mean you are stupid.
It just means you love their music so much that after getting everything you've been allowed to swap with other collectors, you'd love to listen to something that was never available for you to swap.
I'm sure an mp3 of Hangman (studio take) would be seen as the biggest present in these days of Queen demos famine (will it be because of the WWRY musical?...well that's another story)
Bullwinkle: "...could you please provide some comment... regarding QP attempted stingyness regarding the KYA and MtS Hollywood bonus tracks?"
To be honest with you - I don't know, and I don't know how to answer.
What I do know is that they were "accidently" released, therefore, if it were not for this fortunate mishap (it is my strong opinion) they would still not have seen the light of day.
Whisperer: Sorry just seen your mail (don't know how I missed it). "Do you have the Hangman acetate?" - NO comment!!!
Well JSS I'm not going to ask you if you have the Hangman acetate, but do you know people that have the Hangman studio version, or let me put it this way, Do you believe that the Hangman studio version still exists, and will be on the boxset?
I hope I'm not offending you with this question in any way, It's just out of curiosity.
"A technical note... it's a boxed set of audio recordings... very little video exists of early Genesis, unfortunately!"
There is a lot more early video of Genesis than you think. Unfortunately no major stuff from THE LAMB tour exists. There is lots of stuff from 1973-1974: I've got a 50/60 mins recording of a 1973 gig in very good quality and there's lots of other stuff too, try looking at a Yahoogroups group called "gmDVD".
There's a promo-video for the Archive 1967-1975 boxset, I think JSS was talking about that. The flyer is also used in the cd-boxset though.
There is a lot more early video of Genesis than you think. Unfortunately no major stuff from THE LAMB tour exists. There is lots of stuff from 1973-1974: I've got a 50/60 mins recording of a 1973 gig in very good quality and there's lots of other stuff too, try looking at a Yahoogroups group called "gmDVD".
There's a promo-video for the Archive 1967-1975 boxset, I think JSS was talking about that. The flyer is also used in the cd-boxset though.
Whisperer/Cesar Madarro/EddieVanHalen: "Do you believe that the Hangman studio version still exists, and will be on the boxset"?
I did not wish to go here - so it is my own fault, but seeing as this is going to become a FAQ.
I hope you see this as a moral dilema. Over the past few days - some have given me a hard time. "Biggest dick on Queenzone", "Blaggard" -and that's just what the military term "friendly fire"! On the other hand, people want to know more. You tell me what I should do! Some say "keep quite!" - while others say "tell, tell!".
Yes: Hangman studio 10" acetate exists. Yes, I do have a copy. No It will not appear on the boxset.
(I hope that was not rude)
I did not wish to go here - so it is my own fault, but seeing as this is going to become a FAQ.
I hope you see this as a moral dilema. Over the past few days - some have given me a hard time. "Biggest dick on Queenzone", "Blaggard" -and that's just what the military term "friendly fire"! On the other hand, people want to know more. You tell me what I should do! Some say "keep quite!" - while others say "tell, tell!".
Yes: Hangman studio 10" acetate exists. Yes, I do have a copy. No It will not appear on the boxset.
(I hope that was not rude)
You're not rude mr. Stuart and though we'll never listen to many of your rare recordings, I'm infinitely grateful for all the infos you're providing!!
I LOVE THIS MAN!! (was that far too much?)
And I'm happy to know that "Hangman" exists as studio version, guess why...
I LOVE THIS MAN!! (was that far too much?)
And I'm happy to know that "Hangman" exists as studio version, guess why...
Yes: Hangman studio 10" acetate exists. Yes, I do have a copy. No It will not appear on the boxset.
Pray tell, why won't it be on the boxset?
Peace,
Adam.
"Pray tell, why won't it be on the boxset?"
Pretty easy to answer: QP and GB (and even Brian May himself, from what I've been told) always said that a studio version of said song DOESN'T exist; so, unless they are lying and I don't think so, they don't own a single copy of it.
And I guess no one is (rightly? I think so...) willing to donate/sell it to them.
Pretty easy to answer: QP and GB (and even Brian May himself, from what I've been told) always said that a studio version of said song DOESN'T exist; so, unless they are lying and I don't think so, they don't own a single copy of it.
And I guess no one is (rightly? I think so...) willing to donate/sell it to them.
No-one willing to donate, eh? Hmm...
Peace,
Adam.
Peace,
Adam.
Johnn S Stuart wrote:" ... Simply, acetates are "works of reference" recorded on disc, of a night's session in the studio... ".
So does it mean that it's sort of live jam session, that they put on the tape to keep the ideas (sort of pre-takes)?
So does it mean that it's sort of live jam session, that they put on the tape to keep the ideas (sort of pre-takes)?
No-one willing to donate, eh? Hmm...
Peace,
Adam.
Well, I'm sure no-one got them for free, so why should someone "donate" them for free...? Even though I would love to hear that- well...
Adam Baboolal: Pray tell, why won't it be on the boxset?
Adam what do you want me to say? First, stop insulting your own intelligence - work it out. But, if you are asking another question beyond the obvious, how about an old chinese proverb?
"Trick me once, shame on you. Trick me twice, shame on me".
And please - less of the "No-one willing to donate, eh? Hmm..." holier than thou Innuendos.
Life sucks - Deal with it!
Adam what do you want me to say? First, stop insulting your own intelligence - work it out. But, if you are asking another question beyond the obvious, how about an old chinese proverb?
"Trick me once, shame on you. Trick me twice, shame on me".
And please - less of the "No-one willing to donate, eh? Hmm..." holier than thou Innuendos.
Life sucks - Deal with it!
Is Hangman a proper studio version or just some kind of "rehearsal" that was done in one take in five minutes?